Social:Índia pega no laço

From HandWiki
Revision as of 12:40, 5 February 2024 by John Stpola (talk | contribs) (url)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Short description: Phrase in Brazil that translates to "an Indian woman caught by the lasso"
Rapper Katú Mirim [pt] is among many Indigenous Brazilians who have discussed the phrase: "People say "I have a grandmother who was "pega no laço" and I say, 'So? Do you know the name of your people? What memory do you look for in your ancestry?' " [1]

Índia pega no laço is a phrase used in Brazil that translates to "an Indian woman caught by the lasso". The phrase is used by non-Indigenous Brazilians who claim they have an Indigenous female ancestor and is a reference to the male settlers of Brazil allegedly using lassos to capture Indigenous women.

The phrase is particularly used in the South and South-East of Brazil;[2] the phrases "pega a dente de cachorro" (caught in the teeth of a dog) or "pega a casco de cavalo"[3] (horseback) are also used to the same effect in the North, North-East and Centre-West of Brazil.[2]

The phrase has been discussed particularly by Brazilian anthropologists, as well as by Indigenous people themselves. It is regarded as racist and misogynistic,[4] because it is often used to romanticise or make a joke of the supposed abduction and rape of an Indigenous ancestor.[5][6]

Critiques of the phrase

Historicity

The trope of the captured Indigenous (great, great-great) grandmother is a standard origin myth for many Brazilian families but also reflects "in part" the reality of the origins of Brazil's ethnically mixed population.[3] For example, in a paper discussing the phrase, Indigenous academic Mirna P Marinho da Silva Anaquiri reports a quote from a teacher in Goiânia interviewed as part of her fieldwork:

As a child I witnessed an Indian woman arriving at the farm where my father worked, tied to the tail of a horse. The guy riding on the horse, and her, tied with a rope to the horse's tail; this—for me—is that image. And this "pega no laço" [caught in the lasso] is so generalized that it seems common, natural—nobody is shocked.... ..They... locked her in this wooden box.. ..This happened in 1961, I was four years old.

Recent genetic analysis has found that a high proportion of white Brazilians, at least one third, are descended from Indigenous women on the maternal line.[7][8] Though geneticists found this high level of Indigenous maternal ancestry surprising at first, anthropologist Suelen Siqueira Julio argues that is it "echoed" in the stories of the ancestor who was "pega no laço".[2]

Identity

Anthropologist Julie A Cavignac describes how Brazilian families repeat the same story, down the generations: of an Indigenous young woman, kidnapped by a white man, taken far from her in home (in the forest or on the sierra), kept isolated from the rest of the family until she is "tamed" by having children. The image of the wild Indian woman merges with the representation of the natural world - the feminine world corresponding to the primordial time of the Indigenous ascendancy.[3]

Alcida Rita Ramos believes that claiming a distant Indigenous ancestor is a way of claiming an authentic Brazilian identity:

The man in the street may often say that his Indian grandmother was caught with a lasso, by which he means to authenticate his Brazilianness with a metonymic bond with the proverbial "first inhabitants of the land."

Ramos observes that the claim to "Indian blood" is "somewhat of an abstraction with no material cost"; she writes, "The Indian grandmother is like an ornament that one wears one day and puts away the next." Ramos argues that in the Brazilian national imagination, a "good Indian" is one who remotely contributed her blood to the soil of the Brazilian nation but who is far removed from modern day life.[9]

Normalising violence against women

Many other commentators have criticised the phrase as normalizing and trivializing rape and violence against Indigenous women.[10] For example, the Indigenous Brazilian writer and educator Daniel Munduruku, a member of the Munduruku people, has written that it is bizarre for non-Indigenous Brazilians to be proud that their great-grandfather supposedly had raped and enslaved their great-grandmother and forced her to bear unwanted children and make jokes about the pain and suffering she endured.[11] Other critics analyse the violence implicit in the phrase as reflecting an ongoing culture of violence against women, Indigenous and non-Indigenous. For example, Purí commentator, Raial Orutu Puri in a Ted X talk entitled My grandmother was "pega no laço" moves from discussing the violence against her female ancestors, to the violence against her nation, to the violence committed against all Indigenous women and nations, and from there to contemporary violence against women in Brazil.[6] Similarly, in her paper about the phrase, academic Mirna P Marinho da Silva Anaquiri discusses the availability in Brazil of car bumper stickers showing a cowboy lassoing women. She writes:

What is behind, or even at the forefront, of this image is the discourse of rape culture, the implication of taking or roping a woman by force, without consent, reaffirming the place of the man as the owner of the woman's body.

See also

  • Indian princess
  • Indigenous peoples in Brazil
  • La Malinche
  • Native American ancestry
  • Pardo Brazilians
  • Race and ethnicity in Brazil
  • Rape culture
  • Sexual victimization of Native American women
  • White Brazilians

References

  1. Vandreza Amante (2019). "Quem são os pardos no Brasil? A reafirmação identitária da rapper Katú Mirim" (in pt). https://catarinas.info/quem-sao-os-pardos-no-brasil-a-reafirmacao-identitaria-da-rapper-katu-mirim/. 
  2. 2.0 2.1 2.2 Siqueira Julio, Suelen. "Regimes de alteridade na construção de histórias nacionais: a mulher indígena como um duplo Outro". Associacao Brasileira de Antropologia (undated, post-2021). p. 9. https://www.33rba.abant.org.br/arquivo/downloadpublic?q=YToyOntzOjY6InBhcmFtcyI7czozNToiYToxOntzOjEwOiJJRF9BUlFVSVZPIjtzOjQ6IjIzNTAiO30iO3M6MToiaCI7czozMjoiNWJhMGI2NjViNDU3MWRiNDVkMTVjY2JmMDNhNjc0ZTkiO30%3D. 
  3. 3.0 3.1 3.2 Cavignac, Julie A. (2012). "Caboclas brabas e tapuias amansados: uma história mal contada." (in pt). Perigo Iminente 2: 57–63. https://bemvin.org/caboclas-brabas-e-tapuias-amansados-uma-histria-mal-contada-pe.html. Retrieved 17 October 2022. 
  4. ""Expressão 'pega no laço' é estupro naturalizado na cultura", diz Vera De Paula, que lança 'O que Querem as Mulheres'" (in pt). Heloisa Tolipan. https://heloisatolipan.com.br/tv/a-expressao-pega-no-laco-e-o-estupro-naturalizado-na-nossa-cultura-diz-vera-de-paula-produtora-da-serie-o-que-querem-as-mulheres/. Retrieved 9 October 2021. 
  5. ""Pega no laço": por que essa expressão ofende mulheres indígenas". Universo Online. https://www.uol.com.br/universa/noticias/redacao/2019/04/19/pega-no-laco-por-que-essa-expressao-ofende-mulheres-indigenas.htm. Retrieved 9 October 2021. 
  6. 6.0 6.1 Raial Orutu Puri. Avós além do laço [Grandmothers beyond the lasso] (online video) (in Portuguese). Ted X. Event occurs at 4:58. Archived from the original on 9 October 2022. Retrieved 8 October 2022.CS1 maint: unrecognized language (link)
  7. "Marcas genéticas da miscigenação" (in pt). 13 April 2000. https://revistapesquisa.fapesp.br/marcas-geneticas-da-miscigenacao/. 
  8. Cardena, Mari M.S.G; Ribeiro dos Santos, Ândrea; Santos, Sidney; Mansur, Alfredo J.; Pereira, Alexandre C.; Fridman, Cintia (April 2013). "Assessment of the Relationship between Self-Declared Ethnicity, Mitochondrial Haplogroups and Genomic Ancestry in Brazilian Individuals". PLOS ONE 8 (4): e62005. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0062005. PMID 23637946. Bibcode2013PLoSO...862005C. 
  9. Ramos, Alcida Rita (June 2008). "Neither Here nor There. On the Ambiguity of Being Indian in Brazil". VIBRANT - Vibrant Virtual Brazilian Anthropology (Associação Brasileira de Antropologia) 5 (1): 7–19. ISSN 1809-4341. https://www.redalyc.org/pdf/4069/406941905001.pdf. Retrieved 9 October 2021. 
  10. Anaquiri, Mirna P Marinho da Silva. "Minha Avó foi pega a laço : a questão da mulher indigena a partir de um olhar feminista". Anais do Seminário Internacional de Pesquisa em Arte e Cultura Visual (Federal University of Goiás) 2018. https://files.cercomp.ufg.br/weby/up/778/o/LC_MIRNA_ANAQUIRI_IISIPACV2018.pdf. Retrieved 9 October 2021. 
  11. "A Literarura Nativa E O Ensino Das Relações Étnico-Raciais Nos Anos Iniciais Do Ensino Fundamental". University of Campinas. http://repositorio.unicamp.br/bitstream/REPOSIP/363185/1/Moura_AnaKarolinaMirandaDe_M.pdf. Retrieved 9 October 2021. 
Cite error: <ref> tag with name "Ramos0" defined in <references> is not used in prior text.