Unsolved:Death of Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart

From HandWiki
Short description: 1791 death of Austrian composer Mozart
Portrait (1789, two years before his death) of Mozart in silverpoint by Doris Stock

On 5 December 1791, the composer Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart died at his home in Vienna, Austria, at the age of 35. The circumstances of his death have attracted much research and speculation.

The principal sources of contention are:

  1. Whether Mozart declined gradually, experiencing great fear and sadness, or whether he was fundamentally in good spirits toward the end of his life, then felled by a relatively sudden illness;
  2. Whether the cause of his death was from disease or poisoning;
  3. Whether his funeral arrangements were the normal procedures for his day, or whether they were of a disrespectful nature.

There is a range of views on each of these points, many of which have varied radically over time.

The course of Mozart's final illness

Traditional narrative

Constanze Mozart by her brother-in-law Joseph Lange (1782)

Mozart scholarship long followed the accounts of early biographers, which proceeded in large part from the recorded memories of his widow Constanze and her sister Sophie Weber as they were recorded in the biographies by Franz Niemetschek and Georg Nikolaus von Nissen. For instance, the important biography by Hermann Abert largely follows this account.[1] The following is a summary of this view.

When in August 1791 Mozart arrived in Prague to supervise the performance of his new opera La clemenza di Tito (K. 621), he was "already very ill".[2] During this visit, Niemetschek wrote, "he was pale and expression was sad, although his good humour was often shown in merry jest with his friends."[3] Following his return to Vienna (mid September 1791),[4] Mozart's condition gradually worsened.[5] For a while, he was still able to work and completed his Clarinet Concerto (K. 622), worked toward the completion of his Requiem (K. 626), and conducted the premiere performance of The Magic Flute (K. 620) on 30 September. Still, he became increasingly alarmed and despondent about his health. An anecdote from Constanze is related by Niemetschek:

On his return to Vienna, his indisposition increased visibly and made him gloomily depressed. His wife was truly distressed over this. One day when she was driving in the Prater with him, to give him a little distraction and amusement, and they were sitting by themselves, Mozart began to speak of death, and declared that he was writing the Requiem for himself. Tears came to the eyes of the sensitive man: 'I feel definitely,' he continued, 'that I will not last much longer; I am sure I have been poisoned. I cannot rid myself of this idea.'

Constanze attempted to cheer her husband by persuading him to give up work on the Requiem for a while, encouraging him instead to complete the "Freimaurerkantate" (K. 623), composed to celebrate the opening of a new Masonic temple for Mozart's own lodge.[6] The strategy worked for a time – the cantata was completed and successfully premiered on 18 November.[7] He told Constanze he felt "elated" over the premiere.[8] Mozart is reported to have stated, "Yes I see I was ill to have had such an absurd idea of having taken poison, give me back the Requiem and I will go on with it."

Mozart's worst symptoms of illness soon returned, together with the strong feeling that he was being poisoned. He became bedridden on 20 November, suffering from swelling, pain and vomiting.[9]

From this point on, scholars all agreed that Mozart was indeed very sick. He died about two weeks later, at his home in Vienna, on 5 December, at 12:55 am.

Revisionist accounts

The view that Mozart was in near-steady decline and despair during the last several months of his life has been met with much skepticism in recent years. Cliff Eisen supervised the reissue of Abert's biography in 2007 in a new edition, supplementing it with numerous footnotes. While generally deferential to Abert, Eisen expresses sharp criticism in the footnoting of the section leading up to Mozart's death:

in this context, the evidence cited by Abert is selective and suits the intended trajectory of his biography. With the exception of citations from Mozart's letters, all of the testimony is posthumous and prompted by complicated motives both personal and financial. Although it is 'authentic' in the sense that it derives from those who witnessed Mozart's death, or were close to him, it is not necessarily accurate. ... To be sure, Mozart was under the weather in Prague. But there is no evidence that he was 'very ill' and it is not true that his health 'continued to deteriorate'. As Abert himself notes later in this chapter, Mozart's health improved in October and early November.[2]

In the main biography article of the Cambridge Mozart Encyclopedia, Ruth Halliwell writes of the decline-and-despair account:

While later sources describe [Mozart] as working feverishly on [his Requiem], filled with premonitions of his own death, these accounts are hard to reconcile with the high spirits of his letters from most of November. Constanze's earliest account, published in Niemetschek's biography of 1798, states that Mozart 'told her of ... his wish to try his hand at this type of composition, the more so as the higher forms of church music had always appealed to his genius.' There is no hint that the work was a burden to him.

As for why Constanze might have been "prompted by complicated motives both personal and financial" (Eisen), Halliwell contends that "Constanze and Sophie were not objective witnesses, because Constanze's continuing quest for charity gave her reasons to disseminate sentimental and sensationalist views."[10] By "charity" Halliwell may be referring to the many benefit concerts from which Constanze received income in the years following Mozart's death, as well as, perhaps, the pension she received from the Emperor; see discussion below as well as Constanze Mozart.

Christoph Wolff, in a 2012 book entitled Mozart at the Gateway to his Fortune, disputes the view that Mozart's last years represented a steady slide to despair and the grave; he also disagrees with interpretations of the music as reflecting late-life despair (for example) "the hauntingly beautiful autumnal world of [Mozart's] music written in 1791".[11]

Cause of death

Antonio Salieri portrayed by Joseph Willibrord Mähler

Theories involving homicide

An early rumor was that Mozart had been poisoned by his colleague Antonio Salieri; however, this has been proved untrue because the symptoms displayed by Mozart's illness did not indicate poisoning.[12] Despite denying the allegation, Salieri was greatly affected by the accusations and widespread public belief that he had contributed to Mozart's death, which contributed to his nervous breakdowns in later life.[13]

Beyond the Salieri theory, other theories involving murder by poison have been put forth, blaming the Masons, Jews, or both. One such theory was the work of Mathilde Ludendorff, wife of the German general Erich Ludendorff (who were both anti-Semitic). Historian William Stafford describes such accounts as outlandish conspiracy theories.[14]

Theories involving disease

Stafford described the effort to determine what disease killed Mozart:

What did he actually die of? Mozart's medical history is like an inverted pyramid: a small corpus of primary documentation supports a large body of secondary literature. There is a small quantity of direct eyewitness testimony concerning the last illness and death and a larger quantity of reporting of what eye witnesses are alleged to have said. Altogether it would not cover ten pages; some of it is vague, and some downright unreliable. All too often later writers have used these data uncritically to support pet theories. They have invented new symptoms, nowhere recorded in the primary sources.[15]

In the parish register, the entry concerning Mozart's death states he died of "severe miliary fever"[16] – "miliary" referring to the appearance of millet-sized bumps on the skin. This does not name the actual disease.

Mozart had health problems throughout his life, suffering from smallpox, tonsillitis, bronchitis, pneumonia, typhoid fever, rheumatism, and gum disease.[17] Whether these played any role in his demise cannot be determined.

Conjectures as to what killed Mozart are numerous. The following survey is arranged in rough chronological order.

Some ascribe Mozart's death to medical malpractice on the part of his physician, Dr. Closset. His sister-in-law Sophie Weber, in her 1825 account, makes the implication. Borowitz summarizes:

When Mozart appeared to be sinking, one of his doctors, Dr. Nikolaus Closset, was sent for and finally located at the theater. However, according to Sophie's account, that drama-lover "had to wait till the piece was over." When he arrived, he ordered cold compresses put on Mozart's feverish brow, but these "provided such a shock that he did not regain consciousness again before he died.[18]

A 1994 article in Neurology suggests Mozart died of a subdural hematoma. A skull believed to be Mozart's was saved by the successor of the gravedigger who had supervised Mozart's burial, and later passed on to anatomist Josef Hyrtl, the municipality of Salzburg, and the Mozarteum museum (Salzburg). Forensic reconstruction of soft tissues related to the skull reveals substantial concordance with Mozart's portraits. Examination of the skull suggested a premature closure of the metopic suture, which has been suggested on the basis of his physiognomy. A left temporal fracture and concomitant erosions raise the question of a chronic subdural hematoma, which would be consistent with several falls in 1789 and 1790 and could have caused the weakness, headaches, and fainting Mozart experienced in 1790 and 1791. Additionally, an episode of aggressive bloodletting used to treat suspected rheumatic fever on the night of December 4, 1791, could have decompensated such a lesion, leading to his death on the following day.[19]

In a 2000 publication, a team of two physicians (Faith T. Fitzgerald, Philip A. Mackowiak) and a musicologist (Neal Zaslaw) reviewed the historical evidence and tentatively opted for a diagnosis of rheumatic fever.[20]

The hypothesis of trichinosis was put forth by Jan V. Hirschmann in 2001.[21]

A suggestion is that Mozart died as a result of his hypochondriasis and his predilection for taking patent medicines containing antimony. In his final days, this was compounded by further prescriptions of antimony to relieve the fever he clearly suffered.[22]

A 2006 article in a UK medical journal considered several theories for Mozart's death and, based on his letters from his last year, dismisses syphilis and other chronic diseases. The attending physicians wrote he died with fever and a rash, and a physician they consulted wrote later "this malady attacked at this time a great many of the inhabitants and not for a few of them it had the same fatal conclusions and the same symptoms as in the case of Mozart." The article's conclusion was "death came as a result of an acute infectious illness."[23]

In 2009, British, Viennese and Dutch researchers performed epidemiological research combined with a study of other deaths in Vienna at the time of Mozart's death. They concluded that Mozart may have died of a streptococcal infection leading to an acute nephritic syndrome caused by poststreptococcal glomerulonephritis. In Austria this disease was also called "Wassersucht" (dropsy/edema).[24]

In a journal article from 2011, it was suggested that vitamin D deficiency could have played a role in Mozart's underlying medical conditions leading to his death.[25]

Funeral

The funeral arrangements were made by Mozart's friend and patron Baron Gottfried van Swieten. Describing his funeral, the Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians states, "Mozart was buried in a common grave, in accordance with contemporary Viennese custom, at the St. Marx Cemetery outside the city on 7 December." Otto Jahn wrote in 1856 that Salieri, Süssmayr, van Swieten and two other musicians were present.[26]

The common belief that Mozart was buried in a pauper's grave is without foundation. The "common grave" referred to above is a term for a grave belonging to a citizen not of the aristocracy.[27] It was an individual grave, not a communal grave; but after ten years the city had the right to dig it up and use it for a later burial. The graves of the aristocracy were spared such treatment.[28]

Another reason why Mozart was buried in this manner besides Viennese custom was Mozart's disdain for complex burials and rites he viewed as "superstitious".[27]

A description of Mozart's funeral, attributed to Joseph Deiner, appeared in the Vienna Morgen-Post of 28 January 1856:

The night of Mozart's death was dark and stormy; at the funeral, too, it began to rage and storm. Rain and snow fell at the same time, as if Nature wanted to shew her anger with the great composer's contemporaries, who had turned out extremely sparsely for his burial. Only a few friends and three women accompanied the corpse. Mozart's wife was not present. These few people with their umbrellas stood round the bier, which then taken via the Grosse Schullerstrasse to the St. Marx Cemetery. As the storm grew ever more violent, even these few friends determined to turn back at the Stuben Gate, and they betook themselves to the "Silver Snake". Deiner, the landlord, was also present for the funeral.[29]

As Slonimsky notes,[30] the tale was widely adopted and incorporated into Mozart biographies, but Deiner's description of the weather is contrary to records kept of the previous day. The diarist Karl Zinzendorf recorded on 6 December that there had been "mild weather and frequent mist".[31] The Vienna Observatory kept weather records and recorded for 6 December a temperature ranging from 37.9 to 38.8 degrees Fahrenheit (2.8 °C–3.8 °C), with "a weak east wind at all ... times of the day".[32]

Aftermath

Following her husband's death, Constanze addressed the issue of providing financial security for her family; the Mozarts had two young children, and Mozart had died with outstanding debts. She successfully appealed to the Emperor on 11 December 1791 for a widow's pension due to her as a result of Mozart's service to the Emperor as a part-time chamber composer. Additionally, she organized a series of concerts of Mozart's music and the publication of many of her husband's works. As a result, Constanze became financially secure over time.[33]

Soon after the composer's death a Mozart biography was started by Friedrich Schlichtegroll, who wrote an early account based on information from Mozart's sister, Nannerl. Working with Constanze, Franz Niemetschek wrote a biography as well. Much later, Constanze assisted her second husband, Georg Nikolaus von Nissen, on a more detailed biography published in 1826. See Biographies of Mozart.

Mozart's musical reputation rose following his death; 20th-century biographer Maynard Solomon describes an "unprecedented wave of enthusiasm"[33] for his work after he died, and a number of publishers issued editions of his compositions.

What may have been Mozart's skull was exhumed in 1801,[34] and in 1989–1991 it was examined for identification by several scientists.[35][36]

Remembrances of Mozart's death

An 1857 lithograph by Franz Schramm, titled Ein Moment aus den letzten Tagen Mozarts ("Moment from the Last Days of Mozart"). Mozart, with the score of the Requiem on his lap, gives Süssmayr last-minute instructions. Constanze is to the side and the messenger is leaving through the main door.[37]
A portrayal by Joseph Heicke of the journey of Mozart's coffin through a storm to the cemetery. Engraving from about 1860, a few years after the Deiner story appeared.

Individuals present at the time of Mozart's death eventually committed their memories to writing, either on their own or through interviews by others. The stories they told are often contradictory, which may be due in part to some of the events not being recorded until the 1820s, when the witnesses' memories might have faded.

Benedikt Schack, Mozart's close friend for whom he wrote the role of Tamino in The Magic Flute, told an interviewer that on the last day of Mozart's life, he participated in a rehearsal of the Requiem in progress. Schack's questionable[according to whom?] account appeared in an obituary for Schack which was published in the 25 July 1827 issue of the Allgemeine musikalische Zeitung:

On the very eve of his death, [Mozart] had the score of the Requiem brought to his bed, and himself (it was two o'clock in the afternoon) sang the alto part; Schack, the family friend, sang the soprano line, as he had always previously done, Hofer, Mozart's brother-in-law, took the tenor, Gerl, later a bass singer at the Mannheim Theater, the bass. They were at the first bars of the Lacrimosa when Mozart began to weep bitterly, laid the score on one side, and eleven hours later, at one o'clock in the morning (of 5 December 1791, as is well known), departed this life.[38][39]

Biographer Niemetschek relates a vaguely similar account, leaving out a rehearsal:

On the day of his death he asked for the score to be brought to his bedside. 'Did I not say before, that I was writing this Requiem for myself?' After saying this, he looked yet again with tears in his eyes through the whole work.[40]

The widely repeated claim that, on his deathbed, Mozart dictated passages of the Requiem to his pupil Süssmayr is strongly discounted by Solomon, who notes that the earliest reference for this claim dates to 1856. However, Süssmayr's handwriting is in the original manuscript of the Requiem and Sophie Weber did claim to recall that Mozart gave instructions to Süssmayr.[41]

An 1840 letter from the composer Ignaz von Seyfried states that on his last night, Mozart was mentally occupied with the currently running opera The Magic Flute. Mozart is said to have whispered the following to Constanze in reference to her sister Josepha Hofer, the coloratura soprano who premiered the role of the Queen of the Night:

Quiet, quiet! Hofer is just taking her top F;—now my sister-in-law is singing her second aria, "Der Hölle Rache"; how strongly she strikes and holds the B-flat: "Hört! hört! hört! der Mutter Schwur" [Hear! hear! hear! the mother's oath].

Solomon, while noting that Mozart's biographers often left out the "crueler memories" surrounding his death,[41] stated, "Constanze Mozart told Nissen that just before the end Mozart asked her what [his physician] Dr. Closset had said. When she answered with a soothing lie, he said, 'It isn't true,' and he was very distressed: 'I shall die, now when I am able to take care of you and the children.[42] Ah, now I will leave you unprovided for.' And as he spoke these words, 'suddenly he vomited—it gushed out of him in an arc—it was brown, and he was dead.'"[41] Mozart's older, seven-year-old, son Karl was present at his father's death and later wrote, "Particularly remarkable is in my opinion the fact that a few days before he died, his whole body became so swollen that the patient was unable to make the smallest movement, moreover, there was stench, which reflected an internal disintegration which, after death, increased to the extent that an autopsy was impossible."[41]

See also

  • List of unsolved deaths

Notes

  1. ↑ Abert & Eisen 2007, pp. 1305–1309.
  2. ↑ 2.0 2.1 Abert & Eisen 2007, p. 1305.
  3. ↑ Quotation cited from Solomon 1995, p. 487
  4. ↑ Abert & Eisen 2007, p. 1245.
  5. ↑ For this point Solomon 1995, p. 586 cites an article in the Berlin Musikalisches Wochenblatt ("Musical Weekly"), written shortly after Mozart's death.
  6. ↑ Solomon 1995, p. 490.
  7. ↑ Deutsch 1965, p. 413.
  8. ↑ Solomon 1995, p. 490 The words are as related by Constanze decades later to the visiting English diarist Mary Novello.
  9. ↑ Solomon, Maynard. (2005). Mozart: A Life. Harper Perennial, p. 491.
  10. ↑ From Ruth Halliwell's article "Mozart" in The Cambridge Mozart Encyclopedia, p. 332.
  11. ↑ Wolff 2012, Prologue. The quotation, of H. C. Robbins Landon's book Mozart's Last Year, appears on p. 2.
  12. ↑ For discussion, with references, of the poisoning rumor see Solomon 1995, p. 587. The Norton/Grove Concise Encyclopedia of Music states flatly, "He was not poisoned"; see Sadie 1988
  13. ↑ Deutsch 1965, pp. 522, 524.
  14. ↑ Stafford 1991, ch. 2.
  15. ↑ Stafford 1991, p. 56.
  16. ↑ Solomon 1995, p. 494. Numerous sources, even published biographies ([1], [2]), have altered this term to "military fever".
  17. ↑ For a thorough survey of Mozart's health history, with an M.D.'s proposed diagnoses, see Davies 1984.
  18. ↑ Borowitz 1973, pp. 265–266
  19. ↑ Drake Jr, ME (1993). "Mozart's chronic subdural hematoma". Neurology 43 (11): 2400–2403. doi:10.1212/wnl.43.11.2400. PMID 7864907. 
  20. ↑ Fitzgerald, Zaslaw & Mackowiak 2001.
  21. ↑ See [3], and critical comment [4] with reply at [5].
  22. ↑ Emsley 2005, pp. 220–221.
  23. ↑ John Jenkins, "Mozart, portrait and myth," Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, June, 2006, 99(6):288–291, copy available at NIH.
  24. ↑ Zegers, Weigl & Steptoe 2009, pp. 274–278.
  25. ↑ Grant, William B.; Pilz, Stefan (June 2011). "Vitamin D deficiency contributed to Mozart's death". Medical Problems of Performing Artists 26 (2): 117. doi:10.21091/mppa.2011.2019. PMID 21695361. http://www.sciandmed.com/mppa/journalviewer.aspx?issue=1192&article=1908. Retrieved 2011-07-02. 
  26. ↑ Jahn 1867, p. [page needed].
  27. ↑ 27.0 27.1 Solomon 1995, p. 496-497
  28. ↑ "Dies irae, dies illa – Day of wrath, day of wailing: Notes on the commissioning, origin and completion of Mozart's Requiem (KV 626)" by Walther Brauneis (de)
  29. ↑ Deutsch 1965, p. 465.
  30. ↑ Slonimsky 1960, pp. 12–14.
  31. ↑ Deutsch 1965, p. 418 The original French, given by Slonimsky 1960, p. 17, is "temps doux et brouillard frequent".
  32. ↑ Slonimsky 1960, p. 16.
  33. ↑ 33.0 33.1 Solomon 1995, p. 499
  34. ↑ "Le crâne de Mozart". La Chronique Médicale (Paris) (13): 432. 1906. https://www.biusante.parisdescartes.fr/histoire/medica/resultats/?cote=130381x1906x13&do=pdfnone ; from Le Charivari
  35. ↑ Puech, PF (1991). "Forensic scientists uncovering Mozart". Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine 84 (6): 387. doi:10.1177/014107689108400646. PMID 2061918. 
  36. ↑ Puech, Pierre-Francois; Puech, Bernard; Tichy, Gottfried (1989). "Identification of the cranium of W.A. Mozart". Forensic Science International 41 (1–2): 101–110. doi:10.1016/0379-0738(89)90241-7. PMID 2670708. 
  37. ↑ Simon P. Keefe, ed (2006). Mozart Studies. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. pp. 3–4. ISBN 978-0521851022. OCLC 76850387. 
  38. ↑ Deutsch 1965, pp. 536–537.
  39. ↑ Schildkret 2008.
  40. ↑ Niemetschek|1798}}|Niemetschek biography, quoted Solomon 1995, p. 493
  41. ↑ 41.0 41.1 41.2 41.3 Solomon 1995, p. 493
  42. ↑ Mozart's financial condition had improved considerably during the year 1791; see Solomon 1995, ch. 30

References

  • Abert, Herrmann (2007). W. A. Mozart. with new notes by Cliff Eisen. New Haven: Yale University Press. ISBN 9780300072235. 
  • {{Cite journal

| doi = 10.1093/mq/LIX.2.263 | issn = 0027-4631 | volume = 59 | issue = 2 | pages = 263–284 | last = Borowitz | first = Albert I. | title = Salieri and the "Murder" of Mozart | journal = The Musical Quarterly | date = April 1973 | oclc = 483432356

  • {{Cite journal

| doi = 10.2307/963386 | issn = 0027-4666 | volume = 125 | issue = 1698 | pages = 437–442 | last = Davies | first = Peter J. | title = Mozart's Illnesses and Death: 1. The Illnesses, 1756–90 | journal = The Musical Times | date = August 1984 | oclc = 484935994 | jstor = 963386

| doi = 10.7326/0003-4819-151-4-200908180-00010 | pmid = 19687494 | issn = 0003-4819 | volume = 151 | issue = 4 | pages = 274–8, W96-7 | last1 = Zegers | first1 = Richard H. C. | last2 = Weigl | first2 = Andreas | last3 = Steptoe | title = The Death of Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart: An Epidemiologic Perspective | journal = Annals of Internal Medicine | year = 2009 | oclc = 432055514 | citeseerx = 10.1.1.689.7708 | s2cid = 12035323

Further reading



Retrieved from "https://handwiki.org/wiki/index.php?title=Unsolved:Death_of_Wolfgang_Amadeus_Mozart&oldid=3264730"