Unsolved:KBS Tuff
The KBS Tuff (Kay Behrensmeyer Site Tuff) is an ash layer in East African Rift Valley sediments, derived from a volcanic eruption that occurred approximately 1.87 million years ago (Ma). The tuff is widely distributed geographically, and marks a significant transition between water flow and associated environmental conditions around Lake Turkana shortly after 2 Ma. Between 1970-1985 the age of the tuff was the subject of intense academic dispute, with a variety of dates proposed by different geochemical and paleontological laboratories. This dispute came to be known as the KBS Tuff Controversy.
The KBS Tuff has been described as "the Turkana Basin’s most celebrated tephrostratigraphic marker."[1]
Geography
The KBS Tuff was first reported and described by Kay Behrensmeyer (hence "KBS", Kay Behrensmeyer Site) in sediments that belong to Omo Group deposits in southern Ethiopia and northern Kenya. Within this larger group, the KBS has been found in the Shungura Formation in southern Ethiopia, In the Nachukui Formation on the west side of Lake Turkana in northern Kenya, and in the Koobi Fora Formation on the east side of Lake Turkana.[2]
Age and chronological sequence
Argon-argon dating has placed the age of the KBS Tuff at 1.869 ± 0.021 Ma.[3] This age estimate is supported by independent fission track and K/Ar dating methods.[2] KBS is situated above the older Kangaki (2.063 Ma), G-3 (2.188 Ma) and Kalochoro (2.331 Ma) tuffs, and below the younger Malbe (1.843 Ma), Morutot (1.607 Ma) and Lower Ileret (1.527 Ma) tuffs.[3] In some locations tuffs with chemical compositions identical to the KBS tuff have been found in multiple, distinct layers, suggesting that deposition of the layers occurred at various times after eruption.[2]
Within Omo group deposits, the KBS tuff separates distinct sedimentary members of the Nachukui and Foobi Fora formations. In the Nachukui (western) formation, KBS divides the older Kalochoro from the younger Kaitio member. In the Koobi Fora formation, it separates the older Burgi from the younger KBS member.[2]
Environmental context
The KBS Tuff marks a transition in the Turkana Basin from a stable to a fluctuating lake, partly filled by a river and delta system to the north and east of the basin.[4]
Associated hominin remains
In Koobi Fora, on the eastern side of Lake Turkana, a substantial number of hominin fossils have been found immediately below or above the KBS Tuff.[2] A partial list is provided below, including a few specimens from north and west Lake Turkana.
Cranial remains below KBS
- KNM-ER 1470
- KNM-ER 1474
- KNM-ER 3735
- KNM-ER 2598
- KNM-ER 5879
- KNM-ER 1813
- KNM-ER 1800
- KNM-ER 3732
- KNM-ER 1501
- KNM-ER 3729
- KNM-ER 1502
- KNM-ER 1812
- KNM-ER 1801
- KNM-ER 1802
- KNM-ER 3731
- KNM-ER 3734
- KNM-ER 1482
- KNM-ER 1469
- KNM-ER 1803
- KNM-ER 1483
- KNM-ER 150
- L.894-1
Cranial remains at or above KBS
- KNM-ER 1590
- KNM-ER 1593
- KNM-ER 1805
- KNM-ER 407
- KNM-ER 814
- KNM-ER 1804
- KNM-ER 164
- KNM-ER 3733
- KNM-ER 1808
- KNM-ER 1821
- KNM-ER 734
- KNM-ER 807
- KNM-ER 406
- KNM-ER 732
- KNM-ER 730
- KNM-ER 1170
- KNM-WT 1740
KBS Tuff controversy
The KBS Tuff was first dated in 1969, after Behrensmeyer discovered stone tools at Koobi Fora in the layer of the Tuff. Argon/Argon dating was performed by Frank Fitch at Birckbeck College in London and Jack Miller at the University of Cambridge in Cambridge, UK, who found a most likely age of 2.61 Ma for the KBS eruption.[5] This find had important implications for the anthropological community because it provided a very old age for the tools found by Behresmeyer, and for associated crania including KNM-ER 1470, attributed to the genus Homo.[6]
The date was called into question because efforts to replicate the findings produced KBS Tuff ages ranging from less than 1 to over 220 Ma. A study of pig molar anatomy from the site, by Vincent Maglio and Basil Cooke, suggested an age closer to 2 Ma or even less, using methods of biogeochronology.[6] Similar investigation using antelope remains by Alan Gentry at the British Museum of Natural History also contradicted the Argon-Argon 2.6 Ma Tuff.[6] Another problem that emerged was that the 2.6 Ma date for the KBS Tuff, provided by Fitch and Miller, made alignment of the Koobi Fora (east Turkana) geochronology with the Omo (north Turkana) geochronology impossible.[6]
The conflict was resolved after geochemist Garniss Curtis and his student Thure E. Cerling conducted independent investigations of the age of the KBS Tuff using Argon-Argon and Potassium-Argon dating at the Berkeley Geochronology Laboratory. Curtis and Cerling found that the material dated by the Cambridge team actually belonged to two separate tuffs, which they estimated at 1.8 and 1.6 Ma.[6] This date was confirmed by Potassium-Argon dating conducted by Ian McDougall, and later Fission-Track dating conducted by Andy Gleadow.[6] [7][8]
See also
- Meave Leakey
- Richard Leakey
- Francis Harold Brown
- Thure E. Cerling
References
- ↑ Feibel, Craig (2011). "A Geological History of the Turkana Basin". Evolutionary Anthropology 20 (6): 206–216. doi:10.1002/evan.20331. PMID 22170690.
- ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 Feibel, Craig; Brown, Francis; McDougall, Ian (1989). "Stratigraphic Context of Fossil Hominids From the Omo Group Deposits: Northern Turkana Basin, Kenya and Ethiopia". American Journal of Physical Anthropology 78 (4): 595–622. doi:10.1002/ajpa.1330780412. PMID 2712166.
- ↑ 3.0 3.1 Brown, Francis; McDougall, Ian; Gathogo, Patrick (2013). "Age Ranges of Australopithecus Species, Kenya, Ethiopia, and Tanzania". in Reed, Kay; Fleagle, John; Leakey, Richard. The Paleobiology of Australopithecus. Dordrecht: Springer. pp. 8–11.
- ↑ Rogers, Michael; Harris, John; Craig, Feibel (1994). "Changing patterns land use Plio-Pleistocene hominids Lake Turkana Basin". Journal of Human Evolution 27: 139–158. doi:10.1006/jhev.1994.1039.
- ↑ Fitch, FJ; Miller, JA (1970). "Radioisotopic Age Determinations of Lake Rudolf Artefact Site". Nature 226 (5242): 226–228. doi:10.1038/226226a0. PMID 16057186.
- ↑ 6.0 6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 Lewin, Roger (1997). Bones of Contention: Controversies in the Search for Human Origins. University of Chicago Press. ISBN 9780226476513. https://books.google.com/books?id=hoBZmtfO-0AC. Retrieved 11 November 2017.
- ↑ Gleadow, Andrew (1980). "Fission track age of the KBS Tuff and associated hominid remains in northern Kenya". Nature 284 (5753): 225–230. doi:10.1038/284225a0. Bibcode: 1980Natur.284..225G.
- ↑ McDougall, Ian (1985). "K-Ar and 40Ar/39Ar dating of the hominid-bearing Pliocene-Pleistocene sequence at Koobi Fora, Lake Turkana, northern Kenya". GSA Bulletin 96 (2): 159. doi:10.1130/0016-7606(1985)96<159:KAADOT>2.0.CO;2. Bibcode: 1985GSAB...96..159M.
 |  |
