Philosophy:Nobel disease
Nobel disease or Nobelitis is the embrace of strange or scientifically unsound ideas by some Nobel Prize winners, usually later in life.[1][2][3] It has been argued that the effect results, in part, from a tendency for Nobel winners to feel empowered by the award to speak on topics outside their specific area of expertise,[4][5][6] although it is unknown whether Nobel Prize winners are more prone to this tendency than other individuals.[7] Paul Nurse, co-winner of the 2001 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine, warned later laureates against "believing you are expert in almost everything, and being prepared to express opinions about most issues with great confidence, sheltering behind the authority that the Nobel Prize can give you".[8] Nobel disease has been described as a tongue-in-cheek term.[5]
Implications
While it remains unclear whether Nobel winners are statistically more prone to critical thinking errors than other scientists, the phenomenon is of interest because it provides an existence proof that being an authority in one field does not necessarily make one an authority in any other field, and, to the extent that winning a Nobel Prize serves as a proxy indicator of scientific brilliance and high general intelligence, such characteristics are not incompatible with irrationality.[9][7]
Nobel disease also serves to demonstrate that, for some prize winners, being universally hailed as correct appears to bolster the individual laureate's confirmation bias more than it does their skepticism.[10] Milton Friedman, winner of the Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences in 1976, said of the Nobel disease, as it relates to his economic thinking towards an "antidote", the following:[11]
I myself have been asked my opinion on everything from a cure for the common cold to the market value of a letter signed by John F. Kennedy. Needless to say the attention [from receiving a Nobel prize] is flattering, but also corrupting. Somehow we badly need an antidote for both the inflated attention granted a Nobel laureate in areas outside his competence and the inflated ego each of us is in danger of acquiring. My own field suggests one obvious antidote: competition through the establishment of many more awards. But a product that has been so successful is not easy to replace. Hence, I suspect that our inflated egos are safe for a good long time to come.[11]
Winners reported as examples
Charles Richet
Charles Richet won the 1913 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine for his research on anaphylaxis. He also believed in extrasensory perception, paranormal activity, dowsing, and ghosts.[7]
Linus Pauling
Linus Pauling won the 1954 Nobel Prize in Chemistry for his work on chemical bonds and the Nobel Peace prize in 1962 for his peace activism. A decade before winning the first prize, he was diagnosed with Bright's disease which he treated in part by ingesting vitamin supplements, which he claimed dramatically improved his condition. He later espoused taking high doses of vitamin C to reduce the likelihood and severity of experiencing the common cold. Pauling himself consumed amounts of vitamin C on a daily basis that were more than 120 times the recommended daily intake. He further argued that megadoses of vitamin C have therapeutic value for treating schizophrenia and for prolonging cancer patients' lives. These claims are not supported by the best available science.[9][1][2]
William Shockley
William Shockley, who won the 1956 Nobel Prize in Physics for his invention of the transistor, promoted racialism and eugenics.[4][9]
James Watson
James Watson was awarded the 1962 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine, together with Francis Crick and Maurice Wilkins, "for their discoveries concerning the molecular structure of nucleic acids and its significance for information transfer in living material". Since at least 2000, Watson has consistently and publicly claimed that black people are inherently less intelligent than white people, and that exposure to sunlight in tropical regions and higher levels of melanin cause dark-skinned people to have a higher sex drive.[9][12][13]
Nikolaas Tinbergen
Nikolaas Tinbergen won the 1973 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine for discoveries concerning the organization and elicitation of individual and social behavior patterns in animals. During his Nobel acceptance speech, Tinbergen promoted the widely discredited[14] "refrigerator mother" hypothesis of the causation of autism, thereby setting a "nearly unbeatable record for shortest time between receiving the Nobel Prize and saying something really stupid about a field in which the recipient had little experience."[2] In 1985, Tinbergen coauthored a book with his wife[15] that recommended the use of "holding therapy" for autism, a form of treatment that is empirically unsupported and that can be physically dangerous.[1][9]
Brian Josephson
Brian Josephson won the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1973 for his prediction of the Josephson effect. Josephson has promoted a number of scientifically unsupported or discredited beliefs, including the homeopathic notion that water can somehow "remember" the chemical properties of substances diluted within it, the view that transcendental meditation is helpful for bringing unconscious traumatic memories into conscious awareness, and the possibility that humans can communicate with each other by telepathy.[9]
Kary Mullis
Kary Mullis won the 1993 Nobel Prize in Chemistry for development of the polymerase chain reaction. Mullis disagreed with the scientifically accepted view that AIDS is caused by HIV, claiming that the virus is barely detectable in people with the disease. He also expressed doubt in the evidence for human-caused climate change. In his autobiography, Mullis professed a belief in astrology and wrote about an encounter with a fluorescent, talking raccoon that he suggested might have been an extraterrestrial alien.[4][9]
Luc Montagnier
Luc Montagnier co-discovered HIV in 1980, for which he won the 2008 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine. In 2009, in a non-peer-reviewed paper in a journal that he had founded, Montagnier claimed that solutions containing the DNA of pathogenic bacteria and viruses could emit low frequency radio waves that induce surrounding water molecules to become arranged into "nanostructures". He suggested water could retain such properties even after the original solutions were massively diluted, to the point where the original DNA had effectively vanished, and that water could retain the "memory" of substances with which it had been in contact – claims that place his work in close alignment with the pseudoscientific tenets of homeopathy. He further claimed that DNA sequence information could be 'teleported' to a separate test tube of purified water via these radio waves. He explained this in the framework of quantum field theory.[16][2][17] He has supported the scientifically discredited view that vaccines cause autism and has claimed that antibiotics are of therapeutic value in the treatment of autism.[9]
See also
- Argument from authority
- Dunning–Kruger effect
- History of the Nobel Prize
- Nobel Prize controversies
- Nobel Prize effect
- Sutor, ne ultra crepidam
References
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 Gorski, David (18 August 2008). "High dose vitamin C and cancer: Has Linus Pauling been vindicated?". sciencebasedmedicine.org. https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/high-dose-vitamin-c-and-cancer-has-linus-pauling-been-vindicated/. Retrieved 13 May 2020.
- ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 Gorski, David (4 June 2012). "Luc Montagnier and the Nobel Disease". sciencebasedmedicine.org. https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/luc-montagnier-and-the-nobel-disease/. Retrieved 13 May 2020.
- ↑ Robson, David (2019-08-06) (in en). The Intelligence Trap: Why Smart People Make Dumb Mistakes. W. W. Norton & Company. ISBN 978-0-393-65143-0. https://books.google.com/books?id=yQd1DwAAQBAJ.
- ↑ 4.0 4.1 4.2 Winter, David (8 Oct 2011). "The Nobel disease". Wellington, New Zealand: Science Media Centre. https://sciblogs.co.nz/the-atavism/2011/10/08/the-nobel-disease/.
- ↑ 5.0 5.1 Berezow, Alex (18 December 2016). "Paul Krugman Now Has Nobel Disease". https://www.acsh.org/news/2016/12/18/paul-krugman-now-has-nobel-disease-10609. Retrieved 19 May 2020.
- ↑ Weigmann, Katrin (April 2018). "The genesis of a conspiracy theory: Why do people believe in scientific conspiracy theories and how do they spread?" (in en). EMBO Reports 19 (4). doi:10.15252/embr.201845935. ISSN 1469-221X. PMID 29491005.
- ↑ 7.0 7.1 7.2 Sternberg, Robert J.; Halpern, Diane F. (2020-01-16) (in en). Critical Thinking in Psychology. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-1-108-75530-6. https://books.google.com/books?id=jG_IDwAAQBAJ.
- ↑ Nurse, Paul (2013-10-11). "Attention, Nobel Prize winners! Advice from someone who's already won" (in en). https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/comment/attention-nobel-prize-winners-advice-someone-who-s-already-won-8874646.html.
- ↑ 9.0 9.1 9.2 9.3 9.4 9.5 9.6 9.7 Basterfield, Candice; Lilienfeld, Scott; Bowes, Shauna; Costello, Thomas (May–June 2020). "The Nobel disease: When intelligence fails to protect against irrationality". Skeptical Inquirer 44 (3): 32–37. ISSN 0194-6730. https://skepticalinquirer.org/2020/05/the-nobel-disease-when-intelligence-fails-to-protect-against-irrationality/. Retrieved 12 Jan 2024.
- ↑ Diamandis, Eleftherios P. (1 January 2013). "Nobelitis: a common disease among Nobel laureates?". Clinical Chemistry and Laboratory Medicine (Walter de Gruyter GmbH) 51 (8): 1573–1574. doi:10.1515/cclm-2013-0273. ISSN 1437-4331. PMID 23729580.
- ↑ 11.0 11.1 Friedman, Milton; Friedman, Rose (1998). Two lucky people : memoirs (Paperback edition 1999 ed.). Chicago: The University of Chicago Press. p. 454. ISBN 0-226-26415-7.
- ↑ "Fury at DNA pioneer's theory: Africans are less intelligent than" (in en). The Independent. 18 September 2011. https://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/fury-dna-pioneer-s-theory-africans-are-less-intelligent-westerners-394898.html.
- ↑ Harmon, Amy (1 January 2019). "James Watson Had a Chance to Salvage His Reputation on Race. He Made Things Worse.". https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/01/science/watson-dna-genetics-race.html.
- ↑ Folstein, S.; Rutter, M. (1977). "Genetic influences and infantile autism". Nature 265 (5596): 726–728. doi:10.1038/265726a0. PMID 558516. Bibcode: 1977Natur.265..726F.
- ↑ Tinbergen, N.; Tinbergen, E.A. (1985). Autistic children: New hope for a cure. London: George Allen and Unwin. ISBN 978-0041570106.
- ↑ Montagnier, L; Aissa, J; Giudice, E Del; Lavallee, C; Tedeschi, A; Vitiello, G (8 July 2011). "DNA waves and water". Journal of Physics: Conference Series 306 (1): 012007. doi:10.1088/1742-6596/306/1/012007. Bibcode: 2011JPhCS.306a2007M.
- ↑ Hall, Harriett (20 October 2009). "The Montagnier "Homeopathy" Study". https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/the-montagnier-homeopathy-study/. Retrieved 13 May 2020.
 |  |
