Chain rule for Kolmogorov complexity

Short description: Lower bound for size of software program

The chain rule for Kolmogorov complexity is an analogue of the chain rule for information entropy, which states:

[math]\displaystyle{ H(X,Y) = H(X) + H(Y|X) }[/math]

That is, the combined randomness of two sequences X and Y is the sum of the randomness of X plus whatever randomness is left in Y once we know X. This follows immediately from the definitions of conditional and joint entropy, and the fact from probability theory that the joint probability is the product of the marginal and conditional probability:

[math]\displaystyle{ P(X,Y) = P(X) P(Y|X) }[/math]

[math]\displaystyle{ \Rightarrow \log P(X,Y) = \log P(X) + \log P(Y|X) }[/math]

The equivalent statement for Kolmogorov complexity does not hold exactly; it is true only up to a logarithmic term:

[math]\displaystyle{ K(x,y) = K(x) + K(y|x) + O(\log(K(x,y))) }[/math]

(An exact version, KP(x, y) = KP(x) + KP(y|x*) + O(1), holds for the prefix complexity KP, where x* is a shortest program for x.)

It states that the shortest program printing X and Y is obtained by concatenating a shortest program printing X with a program printing Y given X, plus at most a logarithmic factor. The results implies that algorithmic mutual information, an analogue of mutual information for Kolmogorov complexity is symmetric: I(x:y) = I(y:x) + O(log K(x,y)) for all x,y.

Proof

The ≤ direction is obvious: we can write a program to produce x and y by concatenating a program to produce x, a program to produce y given access to x, and (whence the log term) the length of one of the programs, so that we know where to separate the two programs for x and y|x (log(K(x, y)) upper-bounds this length).

For the ≥ direction, it suffices to show that for all k,l such that k+l = K(x,y) we have that either

K(x|k,l) ≤ k + O(1)

or

K(y|x,k,l) ≤ l + O(1).

Consider the list (a₁,b₁), (a₂,b₂), ..., (a_e,b_e) of all pairs (a,b) produced by programs of length exactly K(x,y) [hence K(a,b) ≤ K(x,y)]. Note that this list

• contains the pair (x,y),
• can be enumerated given k and l (by running all programs of length K(x,y) in parallel),
• has at most 2^K(x,y) elements (because there are at most 2ⁿ programs of length n).

First, suppose that x appears less than 2^l times as first element. We can specify y given x,k,l by enumerating (a₁,b₁), (a₂,b₂), ... and then selecting (x,y) in the sub-list of pairs (x,b). By assumption, the index of (x,y) in this sub-list is less than 2^l and hence, there is a program for y given x,k,l of length l + O(1). Now, suppose that x appears at least 2^l times as first element. This can happen for at most 2^K(x,y)-l = 2^k different strings. These strings can be enumerated given k,l and hence x can be specified by its index in this enumeration. The corresponding program for x has size k + O(1). Theorem proved.

References

• Li, Ming; Vitányi, Paul (February 1997). An introduction to Kolmogorov complexity and its applications. New York: Springer-Verlag. ISBN 0-387-94868-6. 

• Kolmogorov, A. (1968). "Logical basis for information theory and probability theory". IEEE Transactions on Information Theory (Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE)) 14 (5): 662–664. doi:10.1109/tit.1968.1054210. ISSN 0018-9448. 

• Zvonkin, A K; Levin, L A (1970-12-31). "The complexity of finite objects and the development of the concepts of information and randomness by means of the theory of algorithms". Russian Mathematical Surveys (IOP Publishing) 25 (6): 83–124. doi:10.1070/rm1970v025n06abeh001269. ISSN 0036-0279. Bibcode: 1970RuMaS..25...83Z.