Thom space

In mathematics, the Thom space, Thom complex, or Pontryagin–Thom construction (named after René Thom and Lev Pontryagin) of algebraic topology and differential topology is a topological space associated to a vector bundle, over any paracompact space.

Construction of the Thom space

One way to construct this space is as follows. Let

[math]\displaystyle{ p: E \to B }[/math]

be a rank n real vector bundle over the paracompact space B. Then for each point b in B, the fiber [math]\displaystyle{ E_b }[/math] is an [math]\displaystyle{ n }[/math]-dimensional real vector space. Choose an orthogonal structure on E, a smoothly varying inner product on the fibers; we can do this using partitions of unity. Let [math]\displaystyle{ D(E) }[/math] be the unit ball bundle with respect to our orthogonal structure, and let [math]\displaystyle{ S(E) }[/math] be the unit sphere bundle, then the Thom space [math]\displaystyle{ T(E) }[/math] is the quotient [math]\displaystyle{ T(E) := D(E)/S(E) }[/math] of topological spaces. [math]\displaystyle{ T(E) }[/math] is a pointed space with the image of [math]\displaystyle{ S(E) }[/math] in the quotient as basepoint. If B is compact, then [math]\displaystyle{ T(E) }[/math] is the one-point compactification of E.

For example, if E is the trivial bundle [math]\displaystyle{ B\times \R^n }[/math], then [math]\displaystyle{ D(E) = B \times D^n }[/math] and [math]\displaystyle{ S(E) = B \times S^{n-1} }[/math]. Writing [math]\displaystyle{ B_+ }[/math] for B with a disjoint basepoint, [math]\displaystyle{ T(E) }[/math] is the smash product of [math]\displaystyle{ B_+ }[/math] and [math]\displaystyle{ S^n }[/math]; that is, the n-th reduced suspension of [math]\displaystyle{ B_+ }[/math].

The Thom isomorphism

The significance of this construction begins with the following result, which belongs to the subject of cohomology of fiber bundles. (We have stated the result in terms of [math]\displaystyle{ \Z_2 }[/math] coefficients to avoid complications arising from orientability; see also Orientation of a vector bundle.)

Let [math]\displaystyle{ p: E\to B }[/math] be a real vector bundle of rank n. Then there is an isomorphism, now called a Thom isomorphism

[math]\displaystyle{ \Phi : H^k(B; \Z_2) \to \widetilde{H}^{k+n}(T(E); \Z_2), }[/math]

for all k greater than or equal to 0, where the right hand side is reduced cohomology.

This theorem was formulated and proved by René Thom in his famous 1952 thesis.

We can interpret the theorem as a global generalization of the suspension isomorphism on local trivializations, because the Thom space of a trivial bundle on B of rank k is isomorphic to the kth suspension of [math]\displaystyle{ B_+ }[/math], B with a disjoint point added (cf. #Construction of the Thom space.) This can be more easily seen in the formulation of the theorem that does not make reference to Thom space:

Thom isomorphism —  Let [math]\displaystyle{ \Lambda }[/math] be a ring and [math]\displaystyle{ p: E\to B }[/math] be an oriented real vector bundle of rank n. Then there exists a class

[math]\displaystyle{ u \in H^n(E, E \setminus B; \Lambda), }[/math]

where B is embedded into E as a zero section, such that for any fiber F the restriction of u

[math]\displaystyle{ u|_{(F, F \setminus 0)} \in H^n(F, F \setminus 0; \Lambda) }[/math]

is the class induced by the orientation of F. Moreover,

[math]\displaystyle{ \begin{cases} H^k(E; \Lambda) \to H^{k+n}(E, E \setminus B; \Lambda) \\ x \longmapsto x \smile u \end{cases} }[/math]

is an isomorphism.

In concise terms, the last part of the theorem says that u freely generates [math]\displaystyle{ H^*(E, E \setminus B; \Lambda) }[/math] as a right [math]\displaystyle{ H^*(E; \Lambda) }[/math]-module. The class u is usually called the Thom class of E. Since the pullback [math]\displaystyle{ p^*: H^*(B; \Lambda) \to H^*(E; \Lambda) }[/math] is a ring isomorphism, [math]\displaystyle{ \Phi }[/math] is given by the equation:

[math]\displaystyle{ \Phi(b) = p^*(b) \smile u. }[/math]

In particular, the Thom isomorphism sends the identity element of [math]\displaystyle{ H^*(B) }[/math] to u. Note: for this formula to make sense, u is treated as an element of (we drop the ring [math]\displaystyle{ \Lambda }[/math])

[math]\displaystyle{ \tilde{H}^n(T(E)) = H^n(\operatorname{Sph}(E), B) \simeq H^n(E, E \setminus B). }[/math]

The standard reference for the Thom isomorphism is the book by Bott and Tu.

Significance of Thom's work

In his 1952 paper, Thom showed that the Thom class, the Stiefel–Whitney classes, and the Steenrod operations were all related. He used these ideas to prove in the 1954 paper Quelques propriétés globales des variétés differentiables that the cobordism groups could be computed as the homotopy groups of certain Thom spaces MG(n). The proof depends on and is intimately related to the transversality properties of smooth manifolds—see Thom transversality theorem. By reversing this construction, John Milnor and Sergei Novikov (among many others) were able to answer questions about the existence and uniqueness of high-dimensional manifolds: this is now known as surgery theory. In addition, the spaces MG(n) fit together to form spectra MG now known as Thom spectra, and the cobordism groups are in fact stable. Thom's construction thus also unifies differential topology and stable homotopy theory, and is in particular integral to our knowledge of the stable homotopy groups of spheres.

If the Steenrod operations are available, we can use them and the isomorphism of the theorem to construct the Stiefel–Whitney classes. Recall that the Steenrod operations (mod 2) are natural transformations

[math]\displaystyle{ Sq^i : H^m(-; \Z_2) \to H^{m+i}(-; \Z_2), }[/math]

defined for all nonnegative integers m. If [math]\displaystyle{ i=m }[/math], then [math]\displaystyle{ Sq^i }[/math] coincides with the cup square. We can define the ith Stiefel–Whitney class [math]\displaystyle{ w_i(p) }[/math] of the vector bundle [math]\displaystyle{ p: E\to B }[/math] by:

[math]\displaystyle{ w_i(p) = \Phi^{-1}(Sq^i(\Phi(1))) = \Phi^{-1}(Sq^i(u)). }[/math]

Consequences for differentiable manifolds

If we take the bundle in the above to be the tangent bundle of a smooth manifold, the conclusion of the above is called the Wu formula, and has the following strong consequence: since the Steenrod operations are invariant under homotopy equivalence, we conclude that the Stiefel–Whitney classes of a manifold are as well. This is an extraordinary result that does not generalize to other characteristic classes. There exists a similar famous and difficult result establishing topological invariance for rational Pontryagin classes, due to Sergei Novikov.

Thom spectrum

Real cobordism

There are two ways to think about bordism: one as considering two [math]\displaystyle{ n }[/math]-manifolds [math]\displaystyle{ M,M' }[/math] are cobordant if there is an [math]\displaystyle{ (n+1) }[/math]-manifold with boundary [math]\displaystyle{ W }[/math] such that

[math]\displaystyle{ \partial W = M \coprod M' }[/math]

Another technique to encode this kind of information is to take an embedding [math]\displaystyle{ M \hookrightarrow \R^{N + n} }[/math] and considering the normal bundle

[math]\displaystyle{ \nu: N_{\R^{N+n}/M} \to M }[/math]

The embedded manifold together with the isomorphism class of the normal bundle actually encodes the same information as the cobordism class [math]\displaystyle{ [M] }[/math]. This can be shown by using a cobordism [math]\displaystyle{ W }[/math] and finding an embedding to some [math]\displaystyle{ \R^{N_W + n}\times [0,1] }[/math] which gives a homotopy class of maps to the Thom space [math]\displaystyle{ MO(n) }[/math] defined below. Showing the isomorphism of

[math]\displaystyle{ \pi_nMO \cong \Omega^O_n }[/math]

requires a little more work.

Definition of Thom spectrum

By definition, the Thom spectrum is a sequence of Thom spaces

[math]\displaystyle{ MO(n) = T(\gamma^n) }[/math]

where we wrote [math]\displaystyle{ \gamma^n\to BO(n) }[/math] for the universal vector bundle of rank n. The sequence forms a spectrum. A theorem of Thom says that [math]\displaystyle{ \pi_*(MO) }[/math] is the unoriented cobordism ring; the proof of this theorem relies crucially on Thom’s transversality theorem. The lack of transversality prevents from computing cobordism rings of, say, topological manifolds from Thom spectra.

See also

• Cobordism
• Cohomology operation
• Steenrod problem
• Hattori–Stong theorem

References

• Sullivan, Dennis (2004). "René Thom's Work on Geometric Homology and Bordism". Bulletin of the American Mathematical Society 41 (3): 341–350. doi:10.1090/S0273-0979-04-01026-2. 
• Bott, Raoul; Tu, Loring (1982). Differential Forms in Algebraic Topology. New York: Springer. ISBN 0-387-90613-4.  A classic reference for differential topology, treating the link to Poincaré duality, Euler class of Sphere bundles, Thom classes and Thom isomorphism, and more.
• Milnor, John. Characteristic classes.  is another standard reference for the Thom class and Thom isomorphism. See especially the paragraph 18.
• May, J. Peter (1999). A Concise Course in Algebraic Topology. University of Chicago Press. pp. 183–198. ISBN 0-226-51182-0.  This textbook gives a detailed construction of the Thom class for trivial vector bundles, and also formulates the theorem in case of arbitrary vector bundles.
• "Explanation for the Pontryagin–Thom construction". MathOverflow. https://mathoverflow.net/questions/7375/explanation-for-the-thom-pontryagin-construction-and-its-generalisations. 
• Stong, Robert E. (1968). Notes on cobordism theory. Princeton University Press. 
• Thom, René (1954). "Quelques propriétés globales des variétés différentiables". Commentarii Mathematici Helvetici 28: 17–86. doi:10.1007/BF02566923. 
• Ando, Matthew; Blumberg, Andrew J.; Gepner, David J.; Hopkins, Michael J.; Rezk, Charles (2014). "Units of ring spectra and Thom spectra". Journal of Topology 7 (4): 1077–1117. doi:10.1112/jtopol/jtu009. 

External links

• http://ncatlab.org/nlab/show/Thom+spectrum
• Hazewinkel, Michiel, ed. (2001), "Thom space", Encyclopedia of Mathematics, Springer Science+Business Media B.V. / Kluwer Academic Publishers, ISBN 978-1-55608-010-4, https://www.encyclopediaofmath.org/index.php?title=p/t092680 
• Akhil Mathew's blog posts: https://amathew.wordpress.com/tag/thom-space/