Unsolved:Enfield Poltergeist

From HandWiki
Revision as of 22:14, 22 October 2022 by Smart bot editor (talk | contribs) (simplify)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Part of a series on the
Paranormal
Main articles

Reportedly haunted locations:

Skepticism
Related
Parapsychology

The Enfield Poltergeist is the name given to claimed supernatural activity at 284 Green Street, a council house in Brimsdown, Enfield, England between 1977 and 1979 involving two sisters, aged 11 and 13.[1] Some members of the Society for Psychical Research such as inventor Maurice Grosse and writer Guy Lyon Playfair believed the haunting to be genuine, while others such as Anita Gregory and John Beloff were "unconvinced" and found evidence the girls had faked incidents for the benefit of reporters. Members of the Committee for Skeptical Inquiry, including stage magicians such as Milbourne Christopher, Joe Nickell and Bob Couttie, reviewed the case and criticised paranormal investigators for being overly credulous whilst also identifying features of the case as being indicative of a hoax.[2][3][4]

The story attracted considerable press coverage in British newspapers such as the Daily Mail and Daily Mirror, and has been the subject of books, featured in television documentaries, and dramatised in horror films.

Claims

In August 1977 single parent Peggy Hodgson called police to her rented home in Enfield after two of her four children said that furniture was moving and knocking sounds were heard on walls. The children included Margaret, age 14, and Janet, 11. A police constable said that she saw a chair "wobble and slide".[3] Later claims included disembodied voices, loud noises, thrown rocks and toys, overturned chairs, and children levitating.[1] Over a period of 18 months, more than 30 people, including neighbours, psychic researchers and journalists, said they saw heavy furniture moving of its own accord, objects being thrown across a room and the daughters seeming to levitate several feet off the ground. Many also heard—and recorded—unexplained knocking noises and a gruff voice.[5] The activity in the house attracted considerable press attention and the story was covered in British newspapers such as the Daily Mail and Daily Mirror until reports came to an end in 1979.[3][6]

Investigations

Paranormal

Society for Psychical Research members Maurice Grosse and Guy Lyon Playfair reported "curious whistling and barking noises coming from Janet's general direction." Although Playfair maintained the haunting was genuine and wrote in his later book This House Is Haunted: The True Story of a Poltergeist (1980) that an "entity" was to blame for the disturbances, he often doubted the children's veracity and wondered if they were playing tricks and exaggerating. Still, Grosse and Playfair believed that even though some of the alleged poltergeist activity was faked by the girls, other incidents were genuine.[3][6][7] Janet was detected in trickery; a video camera in the room next door caught her bending spoons and attempting to bend an iron bar.[8][9] Grosse had observed Janet banging a broom handle on the ceiling and hiding his tape-recorder.[10] According to Playfair, one of Janet's voices she called "Bill" displayed a "habit of suddenly changing the topic—it was a habit Janet also had".[4]

When Janet and Margaret admitted "pranking" to reporters, Grosse and Playfair compelled the girls to retract their confession.[3] They were mocked by other researchers for being easily duped.[11]

The psychical researcher Renée Haynes had noted that doubts were raised about the alleged poltergeist voice at the Second International SPR Conference at Cambridge in 1978, where video cassettes from the case were examined.[12] The SPR investigator Anita Gregory stated the Enfield poltergeist case had been "overrated", characterising several episodes of the girls' behaviour as "suspicious" and speculated that the girls had "staged" some incidents for the benefit of reporters seeking a sensational story.[3][6] John Beloff, a former president of the SPR, investigated and suggested Janet was practicing ventriloquism. Both Beloff and Gregory came to the conclusion that Janet and Margaret were playing tricks on the investigators.[13]

Other

American magician Milbourne Christopher briefly investigated, failed to observe anything that could be called paranormal and was dismayed by what he felt was suspicious activity on the part of Janet. Christopher would later conclude that "the poltergeist was nothing more than the antics of a little girl who wanted to cause trouble and who was very, very, clever."[3] Ventriloquist Ray Alan visited the house and concluded that Janet's male voices were simply vocal tricks.[3]

Sceptical Interpretations

Criticisms of investigations

Sceptic Joe Nickell examined the findings of paranormal investigators and criticised them for being overly credulous; when a supposedly disembodied demonic voice was heard, Playfair noted that, "as always Janet's lips hardly seemed to be moving."

Nickell states that a remote-controlled still camera—the photographer was not present in the room with the girls—timed to take a picture every fifteen seconds was shown by investigator Melvin Harris to reveal "pranking" by the girls. He argues that a photo allegedly depicting Janet levitating actually shows her bouncing off the bed as if it were a trampoline. Harris called the photos examples of common "gymnastics", and said "It's worth remembering that Janet was a school sports champion!"

Nickell asserted that a tape recorder malfunction that Grosse attributed to supernatural activity and Society for Psychical Research president David Fontana described as an occurrence "which appeared to defy the laws of mechanics" was a peculiar threading jam capable of occurring with older model reel to reel tape recorders.[14]

Nickell also claimed that demonologist Ed Warren was "notorious for exaggerating and even making up incidents in such cases, often transforming a "haunting" case into one of "demonic possession".[3]

In 2015, Deborah Hyde commented that there was no solid evidence for the Enfield poltergeist: "... the first thing to note is that the occurrences didn't happen under controlled circumstances. People frequently see what they expect to see, their senses being organised and shaped by their prior experiences and beliefs."[4]

Response to claims

Sceptics have argued that the alleged poltergeist voice that originated from Janet was produced by false vocal cords above the larynx and had the phraseology and vocabulary of a child.[10] In a television interview for BBC Scotland, Janet was observed to gain attention by waving her hand, and then putting her hand in front of her mouth while a claimed "disembodied" voice was heard. During the interview both girls were asked the question "How does it feel to be haunted by a poltergeist?" Janet replied "It's not haunted" and Margaret, in a hushed tone, interrupted "Shut up". These factors have been regarded by sceptics as evidence against the case.[10]

As "a magician experienced in the dynamics of trickery", Nickell examined Playfair's account as well as contemporary press clippings. He noted that the supposed poltergeist "tended to act only when it was not being watched" and concluded that the incidents were best explained as children's pranks.[3] In an interview with the Daily Mail, the adult Janet admitted that she and her sister had faked "2 percent" of the phenomena. This prompted Nickell to comment in another publication, "the evidence suggests that this figure is closer to 100 percent".[6]

Although Maurice Grosse made tape recordings of Janet and believed no trickery was involved, the magician Bob Couttie said, "he made some of the recordings available to me and, having listened to them very carefully, I came to the conclusion that there was nothing in what I had heard that was beyond the capabilities of an imaginative teenager."[10] An article by psychology professor Chris French in 2016 described five reasons why he believed the case to have been a hoax.[15]

In popular culture

  • In 1992 the BBC aired a mockumentary entitled Ghostwatch, written by Stephen Volk and based on the Enfield Poltergeist.[16]
  • In March 2007 Channel 4 aired a documentary about the Enfield poltergeist, entitled Interview with a Poltergeist.[17]
  • The Enfield poltergeist has been featured in episodes of ITV series Strange but True? and Extreme Ghost Stories.
  • The Enfield poltergeist was the subject of the 2015 Sky Living television series The Enfield Haunting, which was broadcast from 4–17 May 2015,[18]
  • The 2016 film The Conjuring 2 is based on the case.[19]
  • In 2018 the BBC Radio 4 programme The Reunion revisited the case, with interviews with people who were involved.[20]

References

  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 Storr, Will. (2015). "The Real Story of the Enfield Haunting". The Daily Telegraph. Retrieved 3 May 2015.
  2. ↑ Couttie, Bob. (1988). Forbidden Knowledge: The Paranormal Paradox. Lutterworth Press. p. 62. ISBN:978-0-7188-2686-4 "The case remains very controversial. Grosse, Playfair, Hasted and others believe it was genuine, Anita Gregory and other members of the SPR were unconvinced. Magicians and ventriloquists came to the conclusion that Janet was cheating."
  3. ↑ 3.0 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 3.7 3.8 3.9 Nickell, Joe. "Enfield Poltergeist". Committee for the Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal. http://www.csicop.org/si/show/enfield_poltergeist. Retrieved 14 April 2018. 
  4. ↑ 4.0 4.1 4.2 Hyde, Deborah. The Enfield 'Poltergeist': A Sceptic Speaks. The Guardian . 1 May 2015. Retrieved 2 May 2015.
  5. ↑ "The Reunion, The Enfield Poltergeist". British Broadcasting Corporation. https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b09yck6b. Retrieved 13 April 2018. 
  6. ↑ 6.0 6.1 6.2 6.3 Joe Nickell (3 July 2012). The Science of Ghosts: Searching for Spirits of the Dead. Prometheus Books. pp. 281–. ISBN 978-1-61614-586-6. https://books.google.com/books?id=oGS67QhECywC&pg=PT281. 
  7. ↑ Playfair, Guy Lyon (1980). This House Is Haunted: The True Story of a Poltergeist. Stein and Day. ISBN 978-0-7387-1867-5. 
  8. ↑ Guiley, Rosemary (1994). The Guinness Encyclopedia of Ghosts and Spirits. Guinness World Records Limited. p. 109. ISBN:978-0851127484
  9. ↑ Clarkson, Michael. (2006). Poltergeists: Examining Mysteries of the Paranormal. Firefly Books. p. 135. ISBN:978-1554071593 "Anita Gregory, of the Society for Psychical Research, who had spent just a short time at the Hodgson home, said the mysterious men's voices were simply the result of Janet and Margaret putting bed sheets to their mouths. In addition, Gregory said that a video camera had caught Janet attempting to bend spoons and an iron bar by force and "practicing" levitation by bouncing up and down on her bed."
  10. ↑ 10.0 10.1 10.2 10.3 Couttie, Bob. (1988). Forbidden Knowledge: The Paranormal Paradox. Lutterworth Press. pp. 62-64. ISBN:978-0-7188-2686-4
  11. ↑ Carlson, H. G. (1994). Mysteries of the Unexplained. Contemporary Books. p. 46. ISBN:978-0809234974
  12. ↑ Haynes, Renée. (1982). The Society for Psychical Research 1882-1982: A History. MacDonald & Co. p. 112. ISBN:978-0356078755
  13. ↑ Clarkson, Michael. (2006). Poltergeists: Examining Mysteries of the Paranormal. Firefly Books. p. 131. ISBN:978-1554071593
  14. ↑ Nickell, Joe. "The Haunted Tape Recorder". Committee for the Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal. http://www.csicop.org/sb/show/haunted_tape_recorder. Retrieved 14 April 2018. 
  15. ↑ "Five reasons why London's most famous poltergeist case is a hoax". Chris French.
  16. ↑ Jagodzinski, Jan (2004). Youth Fantasies: The Perverse Landscape of the Media. Palgrave Macmillan. p. 145. ISBN 978-1-4039-6164-8. 
  17. ↑ Penman, Danny (5 March 2007). "Suburban poltergeist: A 30-year silence is broken". London: Daily Mail. http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-440048/Suburban-poltergeist-A-30-year-silence-broken.html. 
  18. ↑ Morgan, Maybelle (10 April 2015). "Petrified estate agents get the fright of their lives in haunted house practical joke (and the men have the most hysterical reactions)". London: Daily Mail. http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-3033319/Estate-agents-fright-life-fake-haunted-house-promote-Sky-Living-s-Enfield-Haunting.html. 
  19. ↑ Hawkes, Rebecca. "What did the Enfield Haunting have to do with Ed and Lorraine Warren?". The Daily Telegraph. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/film/the-conjuring-2--the-enfield-poltergeist/haunting-ed-lorraine-warren-true-story/. Retrieved 4 September 2016. 
  20. ↑ Whistledown (8 April 2018). "The Enfield Poltergeist". The Reunion. BBC. BBC Radio 4. Retrieved 14 April 2018.

Further reading

  • Couttie, Bob (1988). Forbidden Knowledge: The Paranormal Paradox. Lutterworth Press. ISBN:978-0-7188-2686-4
  • Morris, Rosalind (presenter); Thompson, Sally (producer) (26 December 1978). The Enfield Poltergeist. BBC. BBC Radio 4. Retrieved 15 April 2018. Contemporaneous radio documentary featuring eyewitness contributions and recordings made at the house.
  • Nickell, Joe (2012). The Science of Ghosts: Searching for Spirits of the Dead. Prometheus Books. ISBN:978-1-61614-586-6
  • Playfair, Guy Lyon (1980). This House Is Haunted: The True Story of a Poltergeist. Stein and Day. ISBN:978-0-7387-1867-5

External links




Retrieved from "https://handwiki.org/wiki/index.php?title=Unsolved:Enfield_Poltergeist&oldid=2171148"