Seifert surface

Short description: Orientable surface whose boundary is a knot or link

A Seifert surface bounded by a set of Borromean rings.

In mathematics, a Seifert surface (named after Germany mathematician Herbert Seifert) is an orientable surface whose boundary is a given knot or link.

Such surfaces can be used to study the properties of the associated knot or link. For example, many knot invariants are most easily calculated using a Seifert surface. Seifert surfaces are also interesting in their own right, and the subject of considerable research.

Specifically, let L be a tame oriented knot or link in Euclidean 3-space (or in the 3-sphere). A Seifert surface is a compact, connected, oriented surface S embedded in 3-space whose boundary is L such that the orientation on L is just the induced orientation from S.

Note that any compact, connected, oriented surface with nonempty boundary in Euclidean 3-space is the Seifert surface associated to its boundary link. A single knot or link can have many different inequivalent Seifert surfaces. A Seifert surface must be oriented. It is possible to associate surfaces to knots which are not oriented nor orientable, as well.

Examples

A Seifert surface for the Hopf link. This is an annulus, not a Möbius strip. It has two half-twists and is thus orientable.

The standard Möbius strip has the unknot for a boundary but is not a Seifert surface for the unknot because it is not orientable.

The "checkerboard" coloring of the usual minimal crossing projection of the trefoil knot gives a Mobius strip with three half twists. As with the previous example, this is not a Seifert surface as it is not orientable. Applying Seifert's algorithm to this diagram, as expected, does produce a Seifert surface; in this case, it is a punctured torus of genus g = 1, and the Seifert matrix is

[math]\displaystyle{ V = \begin{pmatrix}1 & -1 \\ 0 & 1\end{pmatrix}. }[/math]

Existence and Seifert matrix

It is a theorem that any link always has an associated Seifert surface. This theorem was first published by Frankl and Pontryagin in 1930. A different proof was published in 1934 by Herbert Seifert and relies on what is now called the Seifert algorithm. The algorithm produces a Seifert surface [math]\displaystyle{ S }[/math], given a projection of the knot or link in question.

Suppose that link has m components (m = 1 for a knot), the diagram has d crossing points, and resolving the crossings (preserving the orientation of the knot) yields f circles. Then the surface [math]\displaystyle{ S }[/math] is constructed from f disjoint disks by attaching d bands. The homology group [math]\displaystyle{ H_1(S) }[/math] is free abelian on 2g generators, where

[math]\displaystyle{ g = \frac{1}{2}(2 + d - f - m) }[/math]

is the genus of [math]\displaystyle{ S }[/math]. The intersection form Q on [math]\displaystyle{ H_1(S) }[/math] is skew-symmetric, and there is a basis of 2g cycles [math]\displaystyle{ a_1, a_2, \ldots, a_{2g} }[/math] with [math]\displaystyle{ Q = (Q(a_i, a_j)) }[/math] equal to a direct sum of the g copies of the matrix

[math]\displaystyle{ \begin{pmatrix} 0 & -1 \\ 1 & 0 \end{pmatrix} }[/math]

An illustration of (curves isotopic to) the pushoffs of a homology generator a in the positive and negative directions for a Seifert surface of the figure eight knot.

The 2g × 2g integer Seifert matrix

[math]\displaystyle{ V = (v(i, j)) }[/math]

has [math]\displaystyle{ v(i, j) }[/math] the linking number in Euclidean 3-space (or in the 3-sphere) of a_i and the "pushoff" of a_j in the positive direction of [math]\displaystyle{ S }[/math]. More precisely, recalling that Seifert surfaces are bicollared, meaning that we can extend the embedding of [math]\displaystyle{ S }[/math] to an embedding of [math]\displaystyle{ S \times [-1, 1] }[/math], given some representative loop [math]\displaystyle{ x }[/math] which is homology generator in the interior of [math]\displaystyle{ S }[/math], the positive pushout is [math]\displaystyle{ x \times \{1\} }[/math] and the negative pushout is [math]\displaystyle{ x \times \{-1\} }[/math].

With this, we have

[math]\displaystyle{ V - V^* = Q, }[/math]

where V^∗ = (v(j, i)) the transpose matrix. Every integer 2g × 2g matrix [math]\displaystyle{ V }[/math] with [math]\displaystyle{ V - V^* = Q }[/math] arises as the Seifert matrix of a knot with genus g Seifert surface.

The Alexander polynomial is computed from the Seifert matrix by [math]\displaystyle{ A(t) = \det\left(V - tV^*\right), }[/math] which is a polynomial of degree at most 2g in the indeterminate [math]\displaystyle{ t. }[/math] The Alexander polynomial is independent of the choice of Seifert surface [math]\displaystyle{ S, }[/math] and is an invariant of the knot or link.

The signature of a knot is the signature of the symmetric Seifert matrix [math]\displaystyle{ V + V^\mathrm{T}. }[/math] It is again an invariant of the knot or link.

Genus of a knot

Seifert surfaces are not at all unique: a Seifert surface S of genus g and Seifert matrix V can be modified by a topological surgery, resulting in a Seifert surface S′ of genus g + 1 and Seifert matrix

[math]\displaystyle{ V' = V \oplus \begin{pmatrix} 0 & 1 \\ 1 & 0 \end{pmatrix}. }[/math]

The genus of a knot K is the knot invariant defined by the minimal genus g of a Seifert surface for K.

For instance:

• An unknot—which is, by definition, the boundary of a disc—has genus zero. Moreover, the unknot is the only knot with genus zero.
• The trefoil knot has genus 1, as does the figure-eight knot.
• The genus of a (p, q)-torus knot is (p − 1)(q − 1)/2
• The degree of a knot's Alexander polynomial is a lower bound on twice its genus.

A fundamental property of the genus is that it is additive with respect to the knot sum:

[math]\displaystyle{ g(K_1 \mathbin{\#} K_2) = g(K_1) + g(K_2) }[/math]

In general, the genus of a knot is difficult to compute, and the Seifert algorithm usually does not produce a Seifert surface of least genus. For this reason other related invariants are sometimes useful. The canonical genus [math]\displaystyle{ g_c }[/math] of a knot is the least genus of all Seifert surfaces that can be constructed by the Seifert algorithm, and the free genus [math]\displaystyle{ g_f }[/math] is the least genus of all Seifert surfaces whose complement in [math]\displaystyle{ S^3 }[/math] is a handlebody. (The complement of a Seifert surface generated by the Seifert algorithm is always a handlebody.) For any knot the inequality [math]\displaystyle{ g \leq g_f \leq g_c }[/math] obviously holds, so in particular these invariants place upper bounds on the genus.

The knot genus is NP-complete by work of Ian Agol, Joel Hass and William Thurston.

It has been shown that there are Seifert surfaces of the same genus that do not become isotopic either topologically or smoothly in the 4-ball.

See also

• Crosscap number
• Arf invariant of a knot
• Slice genus

External links

• The SeifertView programme of Jack van Wijk visualizes the Seifert surfaces of knots constructed using Seifert's algorithm.