Khinchin integral

In mathematics, the Khinchin integral (sometimes spelled Khintchine integral), also known as the Denjoy–Khinchin integral, generalized Denjoy integral or wide Denjoy integral, is one of a number of definitions of the integral of a function. It is a generalization of the Riemann and Lebesgue integrals. It is named after Aleksandr Khinchin and Arnaud Denjoy, but is not to be confused with the (narrow) Denjoy integral.

Motivation

If g : I → R is a Lebesgue-integrable function on some interval I = [a,b], and if

[math]\displaystyle{ f(x) = \int_a^x g(t)\,dt }[/math]

is its Lebesgue indefinite integral, then the following assertions are true:

1. f is absolutely continuous (see below)
2. f is differentiable almost everywhere
3. Its derivative coincides almost everywhere with g(x). (In fact, all absolutely continuous functions are obtained in this manner.)

The Lebesgue integral could be defined as follows: g is Lebesgue-integrable on I iff there exists a function f that is absolutely continuous whose derivative coincides with g almost everywhere.

However, even if f : I → R is differentiable everywhere, and g is its derivative, it does not follow that f is (up to a constant) the Lebesgue indefinite integral of g, simply because g can fail to be Lebesgue-integrable, i.e., f can fail to be absolutely continuous. An example of this is given by the derivative g of the (differentiable but not absolutely continuous) function f(x)=x²·sin(1/x²) (the function g is not Lebesgue-integrable around 0).

The Denjoy integral corrects this lack by ensuring that the derivative of any function f that is everywhere differentiable (or even differentiable everywhere except for at most countably many points) is integrable, and its integral reconstructs f up to a constant; the Khinchin integral is even more general in that it can integrate the approximate derivative of an approximately differentiable function (see below for definitions). To do this, one first finds a condition that is weaker than absolute continuity but is satisfied by any approximately differentiable function. This is the concept of generalized absolute continuity; generalized absolutely continuous functions will be exactly those functions which are indefinite Khinchin integrals.

Definition

Generalized absolutely continuous function

Let I = [a,b] be an interval and f : I → R be a real-valued function on I.

Recall that f is absolutely continuous on a subset E of I if and only if for every positive number ε there is a positive number δ such that whenever a finite collection [math]\displaystyle{ [x_k,y_k] }[/math] of pairwise disjoint subintervals of I with endpoints in E satisfies

[math]\displaystyle{ \sum_{k} \left| y_k - x_k \right| \lt \delta }[/math]

it also satisfies

[math]\displaystyle{ \sum_k | f(y_k) - f(x_k) | \lt \varepsilon. }[/math]

Define the function f to be generalized absolutely continuous on a subset E of I if the restriction of f to E is continuous (on E) and E can be written as a countable union of subsets E_i such that f is absolutely continuous on each E_i. This is equivalent to the statement that every nonempty perfect subset of E contains a portion on which f is absolutely continuous.

Approximate derivative

Let E be a Lebesgue measurable set of reals. Recall that a real number x (not necessarily in E) is said to be a point of density of E when

[math]\displaystyle{ \lim_{\varepsilon\to 0} \frac{\mu(E \cap [x-\varepsilon,x+\varepsilon])}{2\varepsilon} = 1 }[/math]

(where μ denotes Lebesgue measure). A Lebesgue-measurable function g : E → R is said to have approximate limit y at x (a point of density of E) if for every positive number ε, the point x is a point of density of [math]\displaystyle{ g^{-1}([y-\varepsilon,y+\varepsilon]) }[/math]. (If furthermore g(x)  = y, we can say that g is approximately continuous at x.) Equivalently, g has approximate limit y at x if and only if there exists a measurable subset F of E such that x is a point of density of F and the (usual) limit at x of the restriction of f to F is y. Just like the usual limit, the approximate limit is unique if it exists.

Finally, a Lebesgue-measurable function f : E → R is said to have approximate derivative y at x iff

[math]\displaystyle{ \frac{f(x')-f(x)}{x'-x} }[/math]

has approximate limit y at x; this implies that f is approximately continuous at x.

A theorem

Recall that it follows from Lusin's theorem that a Lebesgue-measurable function is approximately continuous almost everywhere (and conversely). The key theorem in constructing the Khinchin integral is this: a function f that is generalized absolutely continuous (or even of "generalized bounded variation", a weaker notion) has an approximate derivative almost everywhere. Furthermore, if f is generalized absolutely continuous and its approximate derivative is nonnegative almost everywhere, then f is nondecreasing, and consequently, if this approximate derivative is zero almost everywhere, then f is constant.

The Khinchin integral

Let I = [a,b] be an interval and g : I → R be a real-valued function on I. The function g is said to be Khinchin-integrable on I iff there exists a function f that is generalized absolutely continuous whose approximate derivative coincides with g almost everywhere; in this case, the function f is determined by g up to a constant, and the Khinchin-integral of g from a to b is defined as [math]\displaystyle{ f(b)-f(a) }[/math].

A particular case

If f : I → R is continuous and has an approximate derivative everywhere on I except for at most countably many points, then f is, in fact, generalized absolutely continuous, so it is the (indefinite) Khinchin-integral of its approximate derivative.

This result does not hold if the set of points where f is not assumed to have an approximate derivative is merely of Lebesgue measure zero, as the Cantor function shows.

References

• Springer Encyclopedia of Mathematics: article "Denjoy integral"
• Springer Encyclopedia of Mathematics: article "Approximate derivative"
• Bruckner, Andrew (1994). Differentiation of Real Functions. American Mathematical Society. ISBN 978-0-8218-6990-1. 
• Gordon, Russell A. (1994). The Integrals of Lebesgue, Denjoy, Perron, and Henstock. American Mathematical Society. ISBN 978-0-8218-3805-1. https://archive.org/details/integralsoflebes0004gord. 
• Filippov, V.V. (1998). Basic Topological Structures of Ordinary Differential Equations. ISBN 978-0-7923-4951-8.