Cubic plane curve

Short description: Type of a mathematical curve

A selection of cubic curves.

In mathematics, a cubic plane curve is a plane algebraic curve C defined by a cubic equation

[math]\displaystyle{ F(x, y, z) = 0 }[/math]

applied to homogeneous coordinates [math]\displaystyle{ (x:y:z) }[/math] for the projective plane; or the inhomogeneous version for the affine space determined by setting z = 1 in such an equation. Here F is a non-zero linear combination of the third-degree monomials

[math]\displaystyle{ x^3, y^3, z^3, x^2 y, x^2 z, y^2 x, y^2 z, z^2 x, z^2 y, xyz }[/math]

These are ten in number; therefore the cubic curves form a projective space of dimension 9, over any given field K. Each point P imposes a single linear condition on F, if we ask that C pass through P. Therefore, we can find some cubic curve through any nine given points, which may be degenerate, and may not be unique, but will be unique and non-degenerate if the points are in general position; compare to two points determining a line and how five points determine a conic. If two cubics pass through a given set of nine points, then in fact a pencil of cubics does, and the points satisfy additional properties; see Cayley–Bacharach theorem.

Singular cubic y² = x² ⋅ (x + 1). A parametrization is given by t ↦ (t² – 1, t ⋅ (t² – 1)).

A cubic curve may have a singular point, in which case it has a parametrization in terms of a projective line. Otherwise a non-singular cubic curve is known to have nine points of inflection, over an algebraically closed field such as the complex numbers. This can be shown by taking the homogeneous version of the Hessian matrix, which defines again a cubic, and intersecting it with C; the intersections are then counted by Bézout's theorem. However, only three of these points may be real, so that the others cannot be seen in the real projective plane by drawing the curve. The nine inflection points of a non-singular cubic have the property that every line passing through two of them contains exactly three inflection points.

The real points of cubic curves were studied by Isaac Newton. The real points of a non-singular projective cubic fall into one or two 'ovals'. One of these ovals crosses every real projective line, and thus is never bounded when the cubic is drawn in the Euclidean plane; it appears as one or three infinite branches, containing the three real inflection points. The other oval, if it exists, does not contain any real inflection point and appears either as an oval or as two infinite branches. Like for conic sections, a line cuts this oval at, at most, two points.

A non-singular plane cubic defines an elliptic curve, over any field K for which it has a point defined. Elliptic curves are now normally studied in some variant of Weierstrass's elliptic functions, defining a quadratic extension of the field of rational functions made by extracting the square root of a cubic. This does depend on having a K-rational point, which serves as the point at infinity in Weierstrass form. There are many cubic curves that have no such point, for example when K is the rational number field.

The singular points of an irreducible plane cubic curve are quite limited: one double point, or one cusp. A reducible plane cubic curve is either a conic and a line or three lines, and accordingly have two double points or a tacnode (if a conic and a line), or up to three double points or a single triple point (concurrent lines) if three lines.

Cubic curves in the plane of a triangle

Suppose that △ABC is a triangle with sidelengths [math]\displaystyle{ a = |BC|, }[/math] [math]\displaystyle{ b = |CA|, }[/math] [math]\displaystyle{ c = |AB|. }[/math] Relative to △ABC, many named cubics pass through well-known points. Examples shown below use two kinds of homogeneous coordinates: trilinear and barycentric.

To convert from trilinear to barycentric in a cubic equation, substitute as follows:

[math]\displaystyle{ x \to bcx, \quad y \to cay, \quad z \to abz; }[/math]

to convert from barycentric to trilinear, use

[math]\displaystyle{ x \to ax, \quad y \to by, \quad z \to cz. }[/math]

Many equations for cubics have the form

[math]\displaystyle{ f(a,b,c,x,y,z) + f(b,c,a,y,z,x) + f(c,a,b,z,x,y) = 0. }[/math]

In the examples below, such equations are written more succinctly in "cyclic sum notation", like this:

[math]\displaystyle{ \sum_{\text{cyclic}} f(x,y,z,a,b,c) = 0 }[/math].

The cubics listed below can be defined in terms of the isogonal conjugate, denoted by X*, of a point X not on a sideline of △ABC. A construction of X* follows. Let L_A be the reflection of line XA about the internal angle bisector of angle A, and define L_B and L_C analogously. Then the three reflected lines concur in X*. In trilinear coordinates, if [math]\displaystyle{ X = x:y:z, }[/math] then [math]\displaystyle{ X^* = \tfrac{1}{x}:\tfrac{1}{y}:\tfrac{1}{z}. }[/math]

Neuberg cubic

Neuberg cubic of triangle △ABC: The locus of X such that if X_A, X_B, X_C are the reflections of A, B, C in the sidelines BC, CA, AB then the lines are concurrent.

Trilinear equation: [math]\displaystyle{ \sum_{\text{cyclic}} (\cos{A} - 2\cos{B}\cos{C})x(y^2-z^2)= 0 }[/math]

Barycentric equation: [math]\displaystyle{ \sum_{\text{cyclic}} (a^2(b^2 + c^2) + (b^2 - c^2)^2 - 2a^4)x(c^2y^2-b^2z^2) = 0 }[/math]

The Neuberg cubic (named after Joseph Jean Baptiste Neuberg) is the locus of a point X such that X* is on the line EX, where E is the Euler infinity point (X(30) in the Encyclopedia of Triangle Centers). Also, this cubic is the locus of X such that the triangle △X_AX_BX_C is perspective to △ABC, where △X_AX_BX_C is the reflection of X in the lines BC, CA, AB, respectively

The Neuberg cubic passes through the following points: incenter, circumcenter, orthocenter, both Fermat points, both isodynamic points, the Euler infinity point, other triangle centers, the excenters, the reflections of A, B, C in the sidelines of △ABC, and the vertices of the six equilateral triangles erected on the sides of △ABC.

For a graphical representation and extensive list of properties of the Neuberg cubic, see K001 at Berhard Gibert's Cubics in the Triangle Plane.

Thomson cubic

Example of Thomson cubic (black curve). X is on the cubic, such that the isogonal conjugate of X (X′) is on the line X(2) – X.

Trilinear equation: [math]\displaystyle{ \sum_{\text{cyclic}} bcx(y^2-z^2)= 0 }[/math]

Barycentric equation: [math]\displaystyle{ \sum_{\text{cyclic}} x(c^2y^2-b^2z^2)= 0 }[/math]

The Thomson cubic is the locus of a point X such that X* is on the line GX, where G is the centroid.

The Thomson cubic passes through the following points: incenter, centroid, circumcenter, orthocenter, symmedian point, other triangle centers, the vertices A, B, C, the excenters, the midpoints of sides BC, CA, AB, and the midpoints of the altitudes of △ABC. For each point P on the cubic but not on a sideline of the cubic, the isogonal conjugate of P is also on the cubic.

For graphs and properties, see K002 at Cubics in the Triangle Plane.

Darboux cubic

Darboux cubic of triangle △ABC: The locus of X such that if D, E, F are the feet of perpendiculars from X to the sidelines BC, CA, AB then the lines AD, BE, CF are concurrent.

Trilinear equation:[math]\displaystyle{ \sum_{\text{cyclic}} (\cos{A} - \cos{B}\cos{C})x(y^2-z^2)= 0 }[/math]

Barycentric equation: [math]\displaystyle{ \sum_{\text{cyclic}} (2a^2(b^2 + c^2) + (b^2 - c^2)^2 - 3a^4)x(c^2y^2-b^2z^2) = 0 }[/math]

The Darboux cubic is the locus of a point X such that X* is on the line LX, where L is the de Longchamps point. Also, this cubic is the locus of X such that the pedal triangle of X is the cevian triangle of some point (which lies on the Lucas cubic). Also, this cubic is the locus of a point X such that the pedal triangle of X and the anticevian triangle of X are perspective; the perspector lies on the Thomson cubic.

The Darboux cubic passes through the incenter, circumcenter, orthocenter, de Longchamps point, other triangle centers, the vertices A, B, C, the excenters, and the antipodes of A, B, C on the circumcircle. For each point P on the cubic but not on a sideline of the cubic, the isogonal conjugate of P is also on the cubic.

For graphics and properties, see K004 at Cubics in the Triangle Plane.

Napoleon–Feuerbach cubic

Trilinear equation: [math]\displaystyle{ \sum_{\text{cyclic}} \cos(B-C)x(y^2-z^2)= 0 }[/math]

Barycentric equation: [math]\displaystyle{ \sum_{\text{cyclic}} (a^2(b^2 + c^2) + (b^2 - c^2)^2)x(c^2y^2-b^2z^2) = 0 }[/math]

The Napoleon–Feuerbach cubic is the locus of a point X* is on the line NX, where N is the nine-point center, (N = X(5) in the Encyclopedia of Triangle Centers).

The Napoleon–Feuerbach cubic passes through the incenter, circumcenter, orthocenter, 1st and 2nd Napoleon points, other triangle centers, the vertices A, B, C, the excenters, the projections of the centroid on the altitudes, and the centers of the 6 equilateral triangles erected on the sides of △ABC.

For a graphics and properties, see K005 at Cubics in the Triangle Plane.

Lucas cubic

Lucas Cubic of triangle △ABC: The locus of a point X such that the cevian triangle of X is the pedal triangle of some point X'; the point X' lies on the Darboux cubic.

Trilinear equation: [math]\displaystyle{ \sum_{\text{cyclic}} \cos(A)x(b^2y^2- c^2z^2)= 0 }[/math]

Barycentric equation: [math]\displaystyle{ \sum_{\text{cyclic}} (b^2+c^2-a^2)x(y^2-z^2)= 0 }[/math]

The Lucas cubic is the locus of a point X such that the cevian triangle of X is the pedal triangle of some point; the point lies on the Darboux cubic.

The Lucas cubic passes through the centroid, orthocenter, Gergonne point, Nagel point, de Longchamps point, other triangle centers, the vertices of the anticomplementary triangle, and the foci of the Steiner circumellipse.

For graphics and properties, see K007 at Cubics in the Triangle Plane.

1st Brocard cubic

First Brocard Cubic: It is the locus of X such the intersections of XA', XB', XC' with the sidelines BC, CA, CB, where △A'B'C' is the first Brocard triangle of triangle △ABC, are collinear. In the figure Ω and Ω′ are the first and second Brocard points.

Trilinear equation:[math]\displaystyle{ \sum_{\text{cyclic}} bc(a^4-b^2c^2)x(y^2+z^2)= 0 }[/math]

Barycentric equation: [math]\displaystyle{ \sum_{\text{cyclic}} (a^4-b^2c^2)x(c^2y^2+b^2z^2)= 0 }[/math]

Let △A'B'C' be the 1st Brocard triangle. For arbitrary point X, let X_A, X_B, X_C be the intersections of the lines XA′, XB′, XC′ with the sidelines BC, CA, AB, respectively. The 1st Brocard cubic is the locus of X for which the points X_A, X_B, X_C are collinear.

The 1st Brocard cubic passes through the centroid, symmedian point, Steiner point, other triangle centers, and the vertices of the 1st and 3rd Brocard triangles.

For graphics and properties, see K017 at Cubics in the Triangle Plane.

2nd Brocard cubic

Trilinear equation: [math]\displaystyle{ \sum_{\text{cyclic}} bc(b^2-c^2)x(y^2+z^2)= 0 }[/math]

Barycentric equation: [math]\displaystyle{ \sum_{\text{cyclic}} (b^2-c^2)x(c^2y^2+b^2z^2)= 0 }[/math]

The 2nd Brocard cubic is the locus of a point X for which the pole of the line XX* in the circumconic through X and X* lies on the line of the circumcenter and the symmedian point (i.e., the Brocard axis). The cubic passes through the centroid, symmedian point, both Fermat points, both isodynamic points, the Parry point, other triangle centers, and the vertices of the 2nd and 4th Brocard triangles.

For a graphics and properties, see K018 at Cubics in the Triangle Plane.

1st equal areas cubic

First equal area cubic of triangle △ABC: The locus of a point X such that area of the cevian triangle of X equals the area of the cevian triangle of X*.

Trilinear equation: [math]\displaystyle{ \sum_{\text{cyclic}} a(b^2-c^2)x(y^2-z^2)= 0 }[/math]

Barycentric equation: [math]\displaystyle{ \sum_{\text{cyclic}} a^2(b^2-c^2)x(c^2y^2-b^2z^2)= 0 }[/math]

The 1st equal areas cubic is the locus of a point X such that area of the cevian triangle of X equals the area of the cevian triangle of X*. Also, this cubic is the locus of X for which X* is on the line S*X, where S is the Steiner point. (S = X(99) in the Encyclopedia of Triangle Centers).

The 1st equal areas cubic passes through the incenter, Steiner point, other triangle centers, the 1st and 2nd Brocard points, and the excenters.

For a graphics and properties, see K021 at Cubics in the Triangle Plane.

2nd equal areas cubic

Trilinear equation: [math]\displaystyle{ (bz+cx)(cx+ay)(ay+bz) = (bx+cy)(cy +az)(az+bx) }[/math]

Barycentric equation:[math]\displaystyle{ \sum_{\text{cyclic}} a(a^2-bc)x(c^3y^2 - b^3z^2) = 0 }[/math]

For any point [math]\displaystyle{ X = x:y:z }[/math] (trilinears), let [math]\displaystyle{ X_Y = y:z:x }[/math] and [math]\displaystyle{ X_Z = z:x:y. }[/math] The 2nd equal areas cubic is the locus of X such that the area of the cevian triangle of X_Y equals the area of the cevian triangle of X_Z.

The 2nd equal areas cubic passes through the incenter, centroid, symmedian point, and points in Encyclopedia of Triangle Centers indexed as X(31), X(105), X(238), X(292), X(365), X(672), X(1453), X(1931), X(2053), and others.

For a graphics and properties, see K155 at Cubics in the Triangle Plane.

See also

• Cayley–Bacharach theorem, on the intersection of two cubic plane curves
• Twisted cubic, a cubic space curve
• Elliptic curve
• Witch of Agnesi
• Catalogue of Triangle Cubics

References

• Bix, Robert (1998), Conics and Cubics: A Concrete Introduction to Algebraic Curves, New York: Springer, ISBN 0-387-98401-1, https://archive.org/details/conicscubicsconc0000bixr .
• Cerin, Zvonko (1998), "Locus properties of the Neuberg cubic", Journal of Geometry 63 (1–2): 39–56, doi:10.1007/BF01221237 .
• Cerin, Zvonko (1999), "On the cubic of Napoleon", Journal of Geometry 66 (1–2): 55–71, doi:10.1007/BF01225672 .
• Cundy, H. M.; Parry, Cyril F. (1995), "Some cubic curves associated with a triangle", Journal of Geometry 53 (1–2): 41–66, doi:10.1007/BF01224039 .
• Cundy, H. M.; Parry, Cyril F. (1999), "Geometrical properties of some Euler and circular cubics (part 1)", Journal of Geometry 66 (1–2): 72–103, doi:10.1007/BF01225673 .
• Cundy, H. M.; Parry, Cyril F. (2000), "Geometrical properties of some Euler and circular cubics (part 2)", Journal of Geometry 68 (1–2): 58–75, doi:10.1007/BF01221061 .
• Ehrmann, Jean-Pierre; Gibert, Bernard (2001), "A Morley configuration", Forum Geometricorum 1: 51–58 .
• Ehrmann, Jean-Pierre; Gibert, Bernard (2001), "The Simson cubic", Forum Geometricorum 1: 107–114 .
• Gibert, Bernard (2003), "Orthocorrespondence and orthopivotal cubics", Forum Geometricorum 3: 1–27 .
• Kimberling, Clark (1998), "Triangle Centers and Central Triangles", Congressus Numerantium 129: 1–295 . See Chapter 8 for cubics.
• Kimberling, Clark (2001), "Cubics associated with triangles of equal areas", Forum Geometricorum 1: 161–171, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/241067469 .
• Lang, Fred (2002), "Geometry and group structures of some cubics", Forum Geometricorum 2: 135–146 .
• Pinkernell, Guido M. (1996), "Cubic curves in the triangle plane", Journal of Geometry 55 (1–2): 142–161, doi:10.1007/BF01223040 .
• Salmon, George (1879), Higher Plane Curves (3rd ed.), Dublin: Hodges, Foster, and Figgis, https://books.google.com/books?id=pYGj2xY5Le4C .

External links

• A Catalog of Cubic Plane Curves (archived version)
• Points on Cubics
• Cubics in the Triangle Plane
• Special Isocubics in the Triangle Plane (pdf), by Jean-Pierre Ehrmann and Bernard Gibert
• "Real and Complex Cubic Curves - John Milnor, Stony Brook University [2016"]. Graduate Mathematics. June 27, 2018. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NfFnanzULhU.  lecture on July 2016, ICMS, Edinburgh at conference in honour of Dusa McDuff's 70th birthday