Conference matrix

In mathematics, a conference matrix (also called a C-matrix) is a square matrix C with 0 on the diagonal and +1 and −1 off the diagonal, such that C^TC is a multiple of the identity matrix I. Thus, if the matrix has order n, C^TC = (n−1)I. Some authors use a more general definition, which requires there to be a single 0 in each row and column but not necessarily on the diagonal.

Conference matrices first arose in connection with a problem in telephony. They were first described by Vitold Belevitch, who also gave them their name. Belevitch was interested in constructing ideal telephone conference networks from ideal transformers and discovered that such networks were represented by conference matrices, hence the name. Other applications are in statistics, and another is in elliptic geometry.

For n > 1, there are two kinds of conference matrix. Let us normalize C by, first (if the more general definition is used), rearranging the rows so that all the zeros are on the diagonal, and then negating any row or column whose first entry is negative. (These operations do not change whether a matrix is a conference matrix.) Thus, a normalized conference matrix has all 1's in its first row and column, except for a 0 in the top left corner, and is 0 on the diagonal. Let S be the matrix that remains when the first row and column of C are removed. Then either n is evenly even (a multiple of 4) and S is skew-symmetric (as is the normalized C if its first row is negated), or n is oddly even (congruent to 2 modulo 4) and S is symmetric (as is the normalized C).

Symmetric conference matrices

If C is a symmetric conference matrix of order n > 1, then not only must n be congruent to 2 mod 4 but also n − 1 must be a sum of two squares; there is a clever proof by elementary matrix theory in van Lint and Seidel. n will always be the sum of two squares if n − 1 is a prime power.

Given a symmetric conference matrix, the matrix S can be viewed as the Seidel adjacency matrix of a graph. The graph has n − 1 vertices, corresponding to the rows and columns of S, and two vertices are adjacent if the corresponding entry in S is negative. This graph is strongly regular of the type called (after the matrix) a conference graph.

The existence of conference matrices of orders n allowed by the above restrictions is known only for some values of n. For instance, if n = q + 1 where q is a prime power congruent to 1 mod 4, then the Paley graphs provide examples of symmetric conference matrices of order n, by taking S to be the Seidel matrix of the Paley graph. The first few possible orders of a symmetric conference matrix are n = 2, 6, 10, 14, 18, (not 22, since 21 is not a sum of two squares), 26, 30, (not 34 since 33 is not a sum of two squares), 38, 42, 46, 50, 54, (not 58), 62 (sequence A000952 in the OEIS); for every one of these, it is known that a symmetric conference matrix of that order exists. Order 66 seems to be an open problem.

Example

The essentially unique conference matrix of order 6 is given by

[math]\displaystyle{ \begin{pmatrix}0 &+1 &+1 &+1 &+1& +1\\+1& 0 &+1 &-1 &-1& +1\\+1& +1& 0 &+1 &-1& -1\\+1& -1& +1& 0 &+1& -1\\+1& -1& -1& +1& 0& +1\\+1& +1& -1& -1& +1& 0 \end{pmatrix} }[/math].

All other conference matrices of order 6 are obtained from this one by flipping the signs of some row and/or column (and by taking permutations of rows and/or columns, according to the definition in use).

Skew-symmetric conference matrices

Skew-symmetric matrices can also be produced by the Paley construction. Let q be a prime power with residue 3 mod 4. Then there is a Paley digraph of order q which leads to a skew-symmetric conference matrix of order n = q + 1. The matrix is obtained by taking for S the q × q matrix that has a +1 in position (i, j ) and −1 in position (j, i) if there is an arc of the digraph from i to j, and zero diagonal. Then C constructed as above from S, but with the first row all negative, is a skew-symmetric conference matrix.

This construction solves only a small part of the problem of deciding for which evenly even numbers n there exist skew-symmetric conference matrices of order n.

Generalizations

Sometimes a conference matrix of order n is just defined as a weighing matrix of the form W(n, n−1), where W(n,w) is said to be of weight w > 0 and order n if it is a square matrix of size n with entries from {−1, 0, +1} satisfying W W^T = w I. Using this definition, the zero element is no more required to be on the diagonal, but it is easy to see that still there must be exactly one zero element in each row and column. For example, the matrix

[math]\displaystyle{ \begin{pmatrix} 1& 0& 1& 1\\ 0& -1& -1& 1\\ 1& -1& 0& -1\\ 1& 1& -1& 0 \end{pmatrix} }[/math]

would satisfy this relaxed definition, but not the more strict one requiring the zero elements to be on the diagonal.

A conference design is a generalization of conference matrices to non-rectangular matrices. A conference design C is an [math]\displaystyle{ N \times k }[/math] matrix, with entries from {−1, 0, +1} satisfying [math]\displaystyle{ W^{\mathrm{T}} W = (N-1)I_k }[/math], where [math]\displaystyle{ I_k }[/math] is the [math]\displaystyle{ k \times k }[/math] identity matrix and at most one zero in each row. The foldover designs of conference designs can be used as definitive screening designs.

Telephone conference circuits

The trivial 2-port conference network

Belevitch obtained complete solutions for conference matrices for all values of n up to 38 and provided circuits for some of the smaller matrices. An ideal conference network is one where the loss of signal is entirely due to the signal being split between multiple conference subscriber ports. That is, there are no dissipation losses within the network. The network must contain ideal transformers only and no resistances. An n-port ideal conference network exists if and only if there exists a conference matrix of order n. For instance, a 3-port conference network can be constructed with the well-known hybrid transformer circuit used for 2-wire to 4-wire conversion in telephone handsets and line repeaters. However, there is no order 3 conference matrix and this circuit does not produce an ideal conference network. A resistance is needed for matching which dissipates signal, or else signal is lost through mismatch.

• 

  Belevitch's implementation of the 6-port ideal conference network

• 

  Belevitch's implementation of the 10-port ideal conference network

As mentioned above, a necessary condition for a conference matrix to exist is that n−1 must be the sum of two squares. Where there is more than one possible sum of two squares for n−1 there will exist multiple essentially different solutions for the corresponding conference network. This situation occurs at n of 26 and 66. The networks are particularly simple when n−1 is a perfect square (n = 2, 10, 26, ...).

References

• Belevitch V (1950). "Theory of 2n-terminal networks with applications to conference telephony". Electrical Communication 27: 231–244. 
• Goethals J.M., Seidel J.J. (1967). "Orthogonal matrices with zero diagonal". Canadian Journal of Mathematics 19: 1001–1010. doi:10.4153/cjm-1967-091-8. 
• Lili Xiao and Dennis K. J. Lin and Fengshan Bai (2012). "Constructing Definitive Screening Designs Using Conference Matrices". Journal of Quality Technology 44 (1): 2–8. doi:10.1080/00224065.2012.11917877. 
• Seidel, J.J. (1991), ed. D.G. Corneil and R. Mathon, Geometry and Combinatorics: Selected Works of J.J. Seidel. Boston: Academic Press. Several of the articles are related to conference matrices and their graphs.
• Colbourn, Charles J.; Dinitz, Jeffrey H. (2007) Handbook of Combinatorial Designs, Boca Raton, Florida: Chapman and Hall/CRC Press, ISBN:1-58488-506-8.
• van Lint, Jacobus Hendricus; Wilson, Richard Michael (2001) A Course in Combinatorics, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, ISBN:0-521-00601-5.
• Stinson, Douglas Robert (2004) Combinatorial Designs: Constructions and Analysis, New York: Springer, ISBN:0-387-95487-2.
• Eric D. Schoen, Pieter T. Eendebak, Peter Goos (2018). "A Classification Criterion for Definitive Screening Designs". Annals of Statistics. 

Further reading

• N. A. Balonin, Jennifer Seberry, "A Review and New Symmetric Conference Matrices", Research Online, University of Wollongong, 2014. Appendix lists all known and possible conference matrices up to 1002.